Belonocnema treatae

Photo: Nonbinary-Naturalist (iNaturalist, CC0)
- Home
- Animals
- Invertebrates
- Belonocnema treatae
Belonocnema treatae · Cynipidae, Hymenoptera
Identification
Size & shape
Belonocnema treatae, sometimes called the live oak pea galler wasp, is a tiny gall wasp. One popular account puts it at about 3 mm long, about the size of a fire ant. Measured specimens span about 0.11–0.16 in (2.8–4.1 mm), and the two generations of its yearly cycle differ in size. Asexual females, which come out of the leaf galls, measure 0.11–0.13 in (2.8–3.2 mm). Sexual females, from the root galls, are larger at 0.14–0.16 in (3.5–4.0 mm). Males average about 0.15 in (3.7 mm), within a range of 3.2–4.1 mm.
The antennae are slender and thread-like, and the number of segments depends on the type of wasp: 13 in the asexual female, 14 in the sexual female and 15 in the male. The first segment of the male's antennal shaft has a scooped-out notch. The clear fore wing is longer than the body and fringed with dense fine hairs. In the asexual generation the wings are long and straight, and these wasps can fly.
Several features are shared by the whole genus. The top of the thorax is smooth and shiny, with a pair of grooves running its full length, and the ridges on the rear of the thorax curve sharply. The front leg carries a long, curved spine on the tibia, which is probably an adaptation for reaching oak rootlets in the soil.
The galls are easier to see than the wasps. The asexual generation's leaf gall is a smooth, pea-like ball about 0.19–0.22 in (4.92–5.50 mm) across on the underside of a live oak leaf. In Texas, the closely related Belonocnema kinseyi makes hard, woody leaf galls 0.12–0.28 in (3–7 mm) across.
Color pattern
Across the genus, body color runs from light yellow through orange to reddish brown. The asexual generation of Belonocnema treatae is yellowish brown, and its fore wing has a distinct areolet, a small closed cell in the vein pattern. The Texas species Belonocnema kinseyi is reddish brown, with dark brown mandible tips and wing veins and only a small, indistinct areolet. All Belonocnema share a strongly angled Rs vein in the fore wing, marked by narrow black stripes that outline a short radial cell.
The leaf galls are round and brown, red or purple. They are hairy and thick-walled and sit on the underside of the leaf or along its veins from summer into fall. They come off the leaf easily, and one popular account compares them to little brown pearls. The root galls of the sexual generation are knobbly, many-chambered clusters on small rootlets. In a related species these clusters are described as velvety and brown to light brown, turning paler after the wasps emerge.
Behavior
Everything this wasp does is tied to its host oak, and the two generations behave in very different ways. In spring, sexual-generation females lay their eggs on the undersides of newly unfurled live oak leaves. They have little time to do it, because the wasps can start galls only on leaves less than 72 hours old. In late fall and winter, asexual-generation females work at ground level instead. They lay eggs into small rootlets just below the soil surface, on the clonal sprouts that live oaks send up from their roots. In both generations the female lays a mixture of venom and proteins along with her eggs, and this mixture sets off gall formation.
The wasps are choosy about mates as well as hosts. In experiments with populations reared on southern live oak and on sand live oak, wasps preferred mates from the oak species they had grown up on. When the host plant was present during the mating trials, matings between wasps from different hosts fell by 47 percent. The two populations also differ in which host they choose to lay on. Since the 2021 revision, the populations on these two oaks have been treated largely as separate species: Belonocnema treatae on southern live oak and Belonocnema fossoria on sand live oak. B. treatae is the stronger flier of the two and has larger wings.
Adults live only a few days, so a visitor is far more likely to notice the galls than the wasps. The brown pea galls can be found on the undersides of live or fallen live oak leaves. A gall with a tiny round hole in it means the wasp has already emerged.
Telling it apart
Belonocnema wasps can be told from other oak gall wasps by two features: the curved spine on the front of the fore tibia, and the angled Rs vein with narrow black stripes in the fore wing.
The three species in the genus are best separated by host and region. Belonocnema treatae lives mostly on southern live oak, from coastal Mississippi eastward, and only rarely on sand live oak. Belonocnema fossoria lives on sand live oak. Belonocnema kinseyi lives on Texas live oak in Texas.
Belonocnema fossoria has a small, curved fore wing with no areolet. Its fore tibia spur is longer than both the basitarsus and the tibial spurs, and the middle tibia also carries a smaller spur. B. treatae and B. kinseyi have uncurved wings with an areolet, which may be small. Their fore tibia spur is shorter than the basitarsus, and the middle tibia has no spur.
B. treatae and B. kinseyi differ in two ways. In the sexual generation, B. treatae has weakly marked pits (foveae) on the scutellum, separated by a broad ridge, while B. kinseyi has deep pits separated by a narrow keel. In the asexual generation, B. treatae is yellowish brown with a distinct areolet, while B. kinseyi is reddish brown with an indistinct one.
The leaf galls of B. treatae on southern live oak cannot be told apart from those of B. fossoria on sand live oak, so the host tree is the guide. On southern live oak, the gall wasp Disholcaspis quercusvirens also makes galls, but these are compound galls on the stems, not round galls on the leaves.
Male and female
The leaf-gall (asexual) generation is all female, while the root-gall (sexual) generation has both males and females. Males are 3.2–4.1 mm long with 15-segmented antennae, sexual females are 3.5–4.0 mm with 14 segments, and asexual females are smaller, 2.8–3.2 mm, with 13.
- Length
- 0.11–0.16 in (2.8–4.1 mm)
Habitat & cover
Habitat requirements
This wasp is a live oak specialist. The genus is found only on the live oaks of the southeastern and southern United States (Quercus section Quercus, series Virentes), and Belonocnema treatae itself lives on southern live oak, Quercus virginiana, and only rarely on sand live oak, Quercus geminata. Studies have recorded it from Florida, Georgia, Alabama, Mississippi, South Carolina and North Carolina. Genetic work divides the old species complex into a western group, from Texas to Mississippi, and an eastern group, from eastern Mississippi eastward, which matches the range of B. treatae.
The wasp needs two parts of the tree at two seasons. Leaf galls form only on newly flushed leaves, so the timing of each year's galls depends on when the host oak puts out new growth. The sexual generation develops on rootlets and young root sprouts, the clonal shoots live oaks send up from their roots near the soil surface. A suitable oak therefore needs fresh spring foliage and young root sprouts within reach of a wasp that has just emerged.
Pea galls also occur on sand live oaks in scrub in southern Florida. In one study there, love vine (Cassytha) had attacked 58 of 2,000 galls, or 2.9 percent. These sand live oak galls fall within what is now mostly considered the range of the sister species Belonocnema fossoria.
Shelter
The wasp's shelter is the gall itself, and each generation builds a different one. The asexual generation develops in a single-chambered, woody, round gall on the underside of a leaf. The gall's hard, lignified outer layer and its tannins protect the larva inside. These leaf galls stay on the tree or on fallen leaves into the cold months, and the adults emerge from them in late fall and winter.
The sexual generation develops underground in fleshy, many-chambered galls on young root sprouts through fall and winter. These root galls stay fibrous and firm until March and April, when the sexual adults emerge.
In both generations the wasp pupates inside the gall. Pupation begins once the gall's outer tissue has hardened and the gall has stopped growing.
Range & movements
The range runs across the southeastern United States from Florida to Texas, across three live oak hosts. The part now called Belonocnema treatae lies from coastal Mississippi eastward.
Adults move twice a year, in step with the oak. The asexual generation emerges from the leaf galls in November and December and flies or crawls to the root sprouts at the base of the tree to lay eggs. The sexual generation emerges from the root galls from mid-March to the end of April, as the host puts out new leaves, and lays on the fresh foliage.
The asexual adults have long, straight wings and can fly. B. treatae leaves its home populations at higher rates than B. fossoria does. Even so, one popular account describes the wasps on a single tree as becoming genetically isolated from their neighbors, so that each tree is like an island with its own inbred population. No figures for home range, daily movements or dispersal distances have been found.
Threats & management
No information was found on how fire, pesticides or water management affect this species.
Natural enemies take a heavy toll. Mortality in gall wasp communities can reach 99 percent, and woodpeckers, chickadees, squirrels and rats also eat the galls. In Texas, the related Belonocnema kinseyi on Texas live oak hosts 24 species of natural enemies in its leaf-gall generation and 4 in its root-gall generation, and some of these keep emerging from the galls for up to two years.
Damage to the host oak can work in the wasp's favor. In Texas, when defoliation delayed the oaks' leaf flush, egg-laying was delayed too. The wasps then took less time from egg to emergence, and their survival against natural enemies rose tenfold.
Love vine is another threat. In Florida scrub, galls that the vine had tapped held mummified wasps 45 percent of the time, against 2 percent of galls the vine had spared.
Life history
Food habits
The larva eats the gall it lives in, and the gall is grown by the oak. The wasp causes the tree to build it from oak tissue, which both shelters and feeds the larva. The gall has a nitrogen-rich inner nutritive layer, similar to seed tissue, inside a tough, lignin-rich outer layer that is laced with tannic acid. To build this structure the wasp changes the expression of nearly a third of the oak's genome in the inner gall tissue.
The host plant is southern live oak, Quercus virginiana, and only rarely sand live oak, Quercus geminata. Nothing was found on whether or what the adults eat.
Life cycle
Belonocnema treatae alternates between a sexual and an asexual generation, a cycle called heterogony, and completes one full cycle each year. The asexual generation is all female. Its females lay unfertilized eggs that develop into the males and females of the sexual generation. Females of both generations have 20 chromosomes (2n=20), while males have 10 (n=10).
The cycle begins in spring. From mid-March to the end of April, sexual adults emerge from the root galls and mate, and the females lay eggs on the undersides of newly unfurled live oak leaves. Each larva sets off a leaf gall, which grows and then hardens. The larva develops through prepupal and pupal stages inside it. Adults of the asexual generation emerge in November and December. In Texas, Belonocnema kinseyi emerges earlier, from mid-October to early November.
These asexual females lay their eggs into rootlets just below the soil surface. Root galls form through fall and winter, and the sexual adults emerge from them the following spring, completing the cycle.
The timing is flexible. In Texas studies on the related species, when egg-laying was delayed by 6 to 8 weeks, development from egg to emergence was shorter. Adults live only a few days.
Conservation
The species is not listed under the Endangered Species Act, and ITIS lists it as a valid species with a verified record. It is described as widely distributed across the southeastern United States and common on its host oaks. No population counts, trends or conservation programs were found.
Cool facts
- The galls are made by the oak's own tissue under the wasp's chemical direction, and scientists have described them as a novel organ.
- To build its gall, the wasp changes the expression of nearly a third of the oak's genome in the inner gall tissue.
- The leaf-gall generation is all female; in Texas, 115 wasps reared from leaf galls of the related species produced no males at all.
- The wasp's two generations look so different, one from a pea gall on a leaf and one from a gall cluster on a root, that they were once thought to be separate species, and the confusion over its taxonomy lasted 160 years.
- Adults are only about 3 mm long, about the size of a fire ant.
- A sexual-generation female has less than 72 hours to lay on a new oak leaf before it becomes too old to gall.
- Love vine can tap into the galls, and galls it attacks often hold mummified wasps.
- A rare wasp discovered in these galls may be a parasite of a parasite.
Where to find it
Timucuan Ecological & Historic Preserve
Jan, Sep
Not on the park's official species list; reported here on iNaturalist.
Canaveral National Seashore
Mar
Not on the park's official species list; reported here on iNaturalist.
Written by

Owner & Lead Guide
Eric founded Viking EcoTours in 2021 after earning a B.S. in Wildlife Conservation from Virginia Tech and leading conservation crews with the Student Conservation Association.
- One hundred and sixty years of taxonomic confusion resolved: Belonocnema gall wasps associated with live oaks in the USA (opens in a new tab), Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society (Oxford Academic)
- Belonocnema (Zenodo treatment of genus) (opens in a new tab), Zenodo / Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society
- Belonocnema kinseyi Weld 1921 (opens in a new tab), Zenodo
- Belonocnema mesoamericana sp. nov. (opens in a new tab), Zenodo
- The Inky Story of the Dinky Oak Gall (Sulak) (opens in a new tab), USGS / UNL Digital Commons
- The Inky Story of the Dinky Oak Gall (PDF) (opens in a new tab), USGS / UNL Digital Commons
- Cynipid gall wasps (opens in a new tab), Current Biology
- Chromosomes of Belonocnema treatae Mayr, 1881 (opens in a new tab), Comparative Cytogenetics
- Chromosomes of Belonocnema treatae (PMC) (opens in a new tab), PubMed Central
- Belonocnema treatae (agamic) (opens in a new tab), Gallformers
- Belonocnema kinseyi (agamic) (opens in a new tab), Gallformers
- Parallel Patterns of Morphological and Behavioral Variation among Host-Associated Populations of Two Gall Wasp Species (opens in a new tab), PLoS ONE / PubMed
- Parallel Patterns ... (PMC) (opens in a new tab), PubMed Central
- Testing the Role of Habitat Isolation among Ecologically Divergent Gall Wasp Populations (opens in a new tab), International Journal of Ecology (Wiley)
- Testing the Role of Habitat Isolation (ResearchGate) (opens in a new tab), ResearchGate
- A test of trade-offs in dispersal and reproduction within and between a sister species pair of specialist insect herbivores (opens in a new tab), Oecologia (Springer)
- Developmental plasticity and reduced susceptibility to natural enemies following host plant defoliation in a specialized herbivore (opens in a new tab), Oecologia (Springer)
- Temporal isolation between sympatric host plants cascades across multiple trophic levels of host-associated insects (opens in a new tab), PubMed Central
- Florida Oaks Host Exciting Parasite-on-Parasite Action (opens in a new tab), Scientific American
- New wasp may be a parasite of a parasite (opens in a new tab), Futurity (Rice University)
- Diversity and distribution of Wolbachia ... heterogonic gall wasp (opens in a new tab), PubMed Central
- The Biology and Ecology of Belonocnema treatae on its Host Plant, Quercus fusiformis (opens in a new tab), Texas State University
- Host plant and spatial influences on the natural enemy community (thesis) (opens in a new tab), Texas State University
- Parasitoids, Hyperparasitoids, and Inquilines Associated With the Sexual and Asexual Generations of Belonocnema treatae (opens in a new tab), Annals of the Entomological Society of America
- ITIS Report: Belonocnema treatae (opens in a new tab), Integrated Taxonomic Information System
