Citrus Flatid Planthopper

Metcalfa pruinosa

  1. Home
  2. Animals
  3. Invertebrates
  4. Citrus Flatid Planthopper

Metcalfa pruinosa

invertebrate

Identification

Size & shape

A tiny, wedge-shaped planthopper that is easy to mistake for a small moth at first glance. Adults are usually 0.22–0.31 in (5.5–8 mm) long, and some sources put the lower end at 3/16 in (about 5 mm). At its widest the body is only 0.08–0.12 in (2–3 mm) across. Like other flatids, it holds its broadly triangular front wings close against the sides of the body, almost vertically. From above it looks narrow and wedge-shaped, flattened from side to side, like a little tent pitched on a twig.

The front wings (tegmina) are strikingly broad, a little over 0.12 in (3 mm) wide. Spread out, they span about 0.67–0.71 in (17–18 mm). The hind wings are up to 0.16 in (4 mm) wide at the base. Two technical features mark the family. Near the leading edge of each forewing is a well-developed cell crossed by many small veins (the costal cell), and the inner rear part of the wing (the clavus) has a granular texture. The hind shins normally carry spines along their sides, and each foot has three segments.

Nymphs are squatter, less than twice as long as they are wide, and slender in side view. Their developing wing pads have a deep V- or U-shaped notch along the back edge. Mature nymphs are about 0.16–0.24 in (4–6 mm) long, not counting the wax filaments that trail from their bodies.

Color pattern

Adults range from brown to gray, and some look partly dark blue. Most of the difference comes from a bluish-white waxy powder that coats the insect in some individuals and is missing or worn off in others. Under the powder, the body is mostly light ochre to yellowish white. The top of the head, the plate behind it, the back of the thorax, the upper abdomen and the forewings are black to blackish brown, except for a yellow vein along the leading edge of the forewing. The powder gives the dark wings a frosted bluish tone. It rubs off over small raised bumps on the wing, so the wing looks sprinkled with tiny black specks, and there can also be small pale spots across the wings.

The best field mark is a pair of dark spots in the basal half of each forewing, near where the wing joins the body; there are often more than two. The hind wings are transparent with a blackish-gray tint and black veins. The eyes are usually orange or reddish, though one observer described them as bright yellow.

Nymphs look quite different. They are mainly white and dressed in fluffy wax. Under the wax the body is white to light green, sometimes tinged ochre. The wax filaments are longest at the tip of the abdomen, where they usually form two "tails", but the fluff can cover the whole nymph and spread over the plant around it. Mature nymphs show brown spots, as the adult wings do.

Behavior

The first sign of this planthopper is usually its wax, not the insect itself. Look for long, curled filaments of white, waxy material on the undersides of tender leaves, at branch tips, and along the stems of trees, shrubs and vines. The wax is light and fluffy. Nymphs make it and hide inside it, and a cottony patch on a stem can hold a crowd of them. Nymphs and adults feed together in dense groups on leaves, young shoots and stems.

Both adults and nymphs can hop like a grasshopper to get somewhere quickly, but they usually walk slowly, which keeps them from being noticed. Nymphs jump readily when disturbed, and that jump tells them apart from mealybugs and aphids, which cannot jump. They don't always jump, though: one observer found a nymph about 0.24 in (6 mm) long under an eggplant leaf that simply walked away, the "fuzz" moving across the leaf without hopping or flying. Adults fly actively, and with their broad, tent-like wings they look much like small moths in flight or at rest.

As they suck sap, the insects pass sticky honeydew, and a black sooty-mold fungus often grows on it. Leaves coated in that mold are another clue that a colony is nearby. Mating involves calling through vibrations sent along the stems and leaves of the host plant, which a person cannot hear. Tiny passengers sometimes come along too: a mite has been seen hitching a ride on a nymph.

Telling it apart

The citrus flatid planthopper is the only member of its genus reported in the United States. It is also the only flatid in the country with this general shape and size and a basically dark color; its closer relatives are usually pale green. The flatid Anormenis chloris is the one most likely to cause confusion, and its adults and nymphs are all white. Mature citrus flatid nymphs show brown spots, as the adult wings do. Nymphs of both species are white, flattened and covered in waxy filaments, and the wax "tails" come in pairs in both, so spots and color are the marks to check.

Acanaloniid planthoppers look similar on the surface, but they lack the cross-veined cell along the leading edge of the forewing, the grainy-textured clavus and the side spines on the hind shins that this species has.

No identification key reliably separates the nymphs from those of their near relatives. Often the circumstances allow a tentative identification, and finding adults among the wax confirms it. The waxy deposits are easy to mistake for mealybugs or cottony cushion scale. Nudge the colony: planthopper nymphs jump, while mealybugs and aphids do not.

Male and female

Females are slightly larger, about 0.31 in (8 mm) long against about 0.28 in (7 mm) for males. The female also has a strong ovipositor for cutting slits in bark to lay her eggs.

Length
0.19–0.31 in (5–8 mm)

Habitat & cover

Habitat requirements

This planthopper is a generalist, at home wherever there are woody plants to feed on. Despite its name it is not tied to citrus. It turns up on a wide variety of trees, shrubs and vines, many of them grown in the ornamental trade, and it occasionally feeds on herbs. Its native range runs from southeastern Canada south to Florida and west to Minnesota, Texas and eastern Colorado, and on into Mexico and the West Indies, including Cuba. In Florida it has been collected in every region of the state.

In Florida it has been recorded on about 40 kinds of plants: citrus, orchard and forest trees, grape and other vines, shrubs and a few herbs. Recorded hosts include seagrape, magnolia, holly, oak, elm, maple and viburnum. The species can live in very different environmental conditions, which helps explain how readily it has settled outside its native range. In Korea, where it was introduced, it attacked many kinds of plants but not conifers.

The insect needs woody stems with bark for its eggs and tender growth for feeding. It lays eggs in bark crevices and twigs, and the nymphs and adults gather on succulent leaves, young shoots and stems. In Florida, adults have been caught in fruit-fly (Steiner) traps and black-light traps.

Shelter

The species spends the winter as eggs tucked into bark. The female scatters her eggs one at a time. She uses her ovipositor to cut a slit in the bark or places the egg in an existing crack or opening. Eggs are put inside twigs, under bark and in cracks in branches, in the corky bark of trees and shrubs. In Texas they have been found scattered singly in the bark of dead citrus twigs. In Korea, females preferred thicker branches, and in Europe the overwintering eggs are found mainly on field maple, Acer campestre.

Nymphs shelter on the undersides of leaves inside their own covering of wax filaments. The wax is thought to protect them from drying out and to make them unpleasant to eat. The species has no pupal stage: the nymphs grow gradually into adults, so there is no pupation site.

Range & movements

Citrus flatid planthoppers do not travel far under their own power. Flight matters only for spreading locally, and in Austria the yearly spread was estimated at only 0.12–0.31 mi (0.2–0.5 km). The newly hatched nymphs make the most noticeable move of their lives. They drop from the trees where they spent the winter as eggs and make their way gradually across the ground to other host plants. In a persimmon orchard in Korea this happened from the end of May to mid-June. Later, the adults go back to trees to lay their eggs soon after they emerge.

Long-distance spread is a human story. The eggs ride in bark and the adults on foliage, so infested plants carry the species, and so does vehicle traffic. It was carried to northeastern Italy in 1979 and has since spread widely across Europe, and it reached Korea by 2005. No territories or migrations are known.

Threats & management

Within its native range the citrus flatid planthopper rarely causes economic damage, except to plants already weakened by something else, such as a freeze. It has been reported damaging the buds of freeze-damaged citrus, and heavy infestations can lead to sooty mold on the honeydew. In nurseries, the waxy fluff on plants lowers their sales quality. Feeding can also stunt shoots, weaken plants and cause wilting. It is not known to carry citrus tristeza virus or peach yellows, and transmission of plant viruses by this species is thought to be rare.

Control is harder than it looks. Adults simply fly away from sprays, so the nymphs are the usual target, but by the time the wax is noticed, the damage may already be done. In Florida, a small dryinid wasp, Psilodryinus typhlocybae, is reported to be a common natural enemy of the nymphs.

In Europe, where the species is an invasive pest, a related parasitoid wasp, Neodryinus typhlocybae, was brought from Connecticut and released in northeastern Italy in 1989, and it gave satisfactory control. One female wasp can parasitize about 60 nymphs. The wasp attacks only this host, so native European planthoppers are spared. The seven-spot ladybird, Coccinella septempunctata, also feeds on the planthopper. The sources give no information on how fire or water management affect the species.

Life history

Food habits

Nymphs and adults both feed on plant sap, which they draw out with piercing, sucking mouthparts. The small nymphs suck sap from stems, and as they grow, nymphs and adults feed in dense groups on leaves, young shoots and stems. Feeding produces large amounts of honeydew, and sooty mold grows on it.

Few insects have so broad a menu. The species has been recorded on more than 200 plant species. In North America it feeds on native plants in 34 genera and 20 families, and in Florida on about 40 kinds of plants. Its foods are mostly trees, shrubs and vines, with vegetables and weeds now and then. Woody hosts include maple, elm, willow, black locust, dogwood, hawthorn, elder, grape and raspberry. Hosts of economic interest include azaleas, basswood, black walnut, camellias, cherry laurel, corn, gooseberry, grape, grapefruit, hollies, magnolias, orange, pawpaw, peach, sassafras, seagrape, viburnum, ash, elm, maple and oak. In Korea it was found on 110 host species in 52 families, and sunflower was especially attractive to both nymphs and adults.

Life cycle

The citrus flatid planthopper has one generation a year. It spends the winter as eggs in bark, and the young hatch in spring. After mating, a female lays about 50 to 100 eggs. She places each one singly, either in an existing opening in the bark or in a slit she cuts with her strong ovipositor.

The nymphs grow without a pupal stage. They pass through five instars, separated by molts, which differ in head size and in the size of the developing wing pads. The last instar is 0.20–0.24 in (5–6 mm) long. Throughout, the nymphs wrap themselves in white wax.

Timing depends on climate. In southern Texas, eggs begin hatching in early March, nymphs take close to two months to develop, the first adults appear 69 days after hatching, and more appear in June. In Florida, records show nymphs from April to June and adults from May to October. Farther north in the southern states, nymphs are most common in June and July, mature by mid-July, and adults last into early October. In Minnesota the eggs hatch in May and adults emerge from July to September. Adults appear to live several weeks. Soon after emerging they return to trees to lay the eggs that will carry the species through the next winter.

Conservation

The citrus flatid planthopper is not listed under the Endangered Species Act, and it needs no protection. In the United States it is described as relatively uncommon and rarely harms its host plants. Outside its native range it is a different story. It is an invasive pest in Europe, where it had spread to 16 countries by about 2010 after its introduction to Italy in 1979, and in Korea. The sources give no population figures or trends.

Cool facts

  • Its scientific name, pruinosa, means "frosty", after the bluish-white waxy powder that coats the adults.
  • Another common name for it is the floury mothbug, and with its tent-like wings it is easily mistaken for a small moth.
  • The nymphs look like tiny tufts of cotton trailing two wax "tails", and they jump when disturbed, which mealybugs cannot do.
  • It has been recorded feeding on more than 200 plant species.
  • Mates call to each other with vibrations sent through the stems and leaves of the host plant.
  • Accidentally carried to Italy in 1979, it spread across Europe, and a parasitic wasp from Connecticut was released there to control it; one female wasp can parasitize about 60 nymphs.

Where to find it

Everglades National Park

May, Jul

Not on the park's official species list; reported here on iNaturalist.

  • Pine rocklands100% of sightings

    About 14,228 acres in the park

From 4 research-grade iNaturalist sightings in the park, placed on the NPS vegetation map (2009).

  1. EENY-329 Citrus Flatid Planthopper, Metcalfa pruinosa (Say) (opens in a new tab), UF/IFAS EDIS
  2. EENY329/IN605: Citrus Flatid Planthopper (opens in a new tab), UF/IFAS Extension
  3. Citrus Flatid Planthopper, Metcalfa pruinosa (Say) (EDIS abstract) (opens in a new tab), UF/IFAS EDIS
  4. Species Metcalfa pruinosa - Citrus Flatid Planthopper (opens in a new tab), BugGuide
  5. White Plant Hopper? - Metcalfa pruinosa (opens in a new tab), BugGuide
  6. Fulgorid nymphs - Metcalfa pruinosa (opens in a new tab), BugGuide
  7. Fuzzy Bug - Immature Hopper? - Metcalfa pruinosa (opens in a new tab), BugGuide
  8. Citrus Flatid Planthopper - Metcalfa pruinosa (photo 66238) (opens in a new tab), BugGuide
  9. Hoppers of North Carolina: Metcalfa pruinosa (opens in a new tab), NC Division of Parks and Recreation
  10. Citrus Flatid Planthopper PDIC Factsheet (opens in a new tab), NC State Extension
  11. Flatid planthoppers (Entomology and Plant Pathology) (opens in a new tab), Oklahoma State University Extension
  12. Citrus flatid planthopper - Insects in the City (opens in a new tab), Texas A&M AgriLife Extension
  13. Citrus Flatid Planthopper (Metcalfa pruinosa) — Minnesota Seasons (opens in a new tab), Minnesota Seasons
  14. Egg Hatching and First Instar Falling Models of Metcalfa pruinosa (opens in a new tab), Insects (MDPI) / PMC
  15. Egg Hatching and First Instar Falling Models of Metcalfa pruinosa (DOI) (opens in a new tab), Insects (MDPI)
  16. Tracing the Invasion and Expansion Characteristics of the Flatid Planthopper in Korea (opens in a new tab), Insects (MDPI) / PMC
  17. Occurrence and Host Plant of Metcalfa pruinosa in Korea (opens in a new tab), ResearchGate (journal paper)
  18. Citrus flatid planthopper - Metcalfa pruinosa, a new pest of ornamental horticulture in the Czech Republic (opens in a new tab), Plant Protection Science (via ResearchGate)
  19. First report of the Nearctic planthopper Metcalfa pruinosa in Poland (opens in a new tab), Journal of Plant Protection Research
  20. First Report of the Nearctic Flatid Planthopper Metcalfa pruinosa in the Republic of Korea (opens in a new tab), ResearchGate (journal paper)
  21. Metcalfa pruinosa: a new pest in Romania (opens in a new tab), ResearchGate (journal paper)
  22. Metcalfa pruinosa - first occurrence in western Romania (opens in a new tab), ResearchGate (journal paper)
  23. Neodryinus typhlocybae (Ashmead). Use and efficacy in biological control (opens in a new tab), FAO AGRIS
  24. Mass occurrence of Metcalfa pruinosa in an agricultural hedgerow at Gödöllő (Hungary) (opens in a new tab), ResearchGate (journal paper)
  25. MX - OTU preview page for Metcalfa pruinosa (opens in a new tab), Insect Museum / Mississippi Entomological Museum data portal
  26. Metcalfa pruinosa: Systematics, Habitat, Life cycle, Struggle (opens in a new tab), Antropocene.it
  27. Metcalfa pruinosa / Citrus flatid planthopper (opens in a new tab), forestpests.eu