Dainty Sulphur

Nathalis iole

Dainty Sulphur (Nathalis iole)

Photo: (c) Pam Kleinsasser, some rights reserved (CC BY)

  1. Home
  2. Animals
  3. Invertebrates
  4. Dainty Sulphur

Nathalis iole · Pieridae, Lepidoptera

invertebrate

Identification

Size & shape

The Dainty Sulphur is the smallest sulphur in North America and the smallest yellow butterfly in Florida. Published wingspans run from about 0.7 to 1.3 in (18–32 mm), and most fall between 3/4 and 1 1/4 in (19–32 mm). The forewing itself is only about 0.5–0.6 in (1.3–1.5 cm) long. It is smaller than other sulphurs, but its forewing is longer and narrower for its size than in the rest of the group, and that elongated shape is one of the marks that sets it apart.

The early stages are just as small. The egg is yellow and spindle-shaped. The caterpillar is slender and is reported to grow to about 5/8 in (1.6 cm). The chrysalis is small and green, with a rounded head rather than the pointed one seen in many other sulphurs.

Color pattern

From above, the wings are lemon yellow. One Florida account calls them greenish-yellow. The forewing has a black tip and a black bar along its trailing edge, and the hindwing has black along its leading margin. The butterfly rarely basks with its wings open, so the upperside is usually seen in flight, when the bright forewing patch shows.

On the underside, the forewing has an orange or yellow patch at the base, orange scaling along the leading edge, and black spots near the outer margin, including one round black spot. The hindwing underside is yellow washed with olive, and its color depends on the season. In the summer form it is pale yellow. In the winter or dry-season form it is a dusty green with much heavier olive scaling. Caterpillars that grow up while the days are getting shorter become winter-form butterflies with three times the usual number of dark scales, and the darker wings soak up the sun's heat better. A white form exists but is very rare.

Males have an orange-red scent patch inside the dark bar on the hindwing. Females have orange-yellow hindwings and more black above.

The caterpillar is green with a green head. It usually has a narrow purple stripe down the back and a pale or thin yellow stripe low along each side, though the stripes vary in width and can look rosy-purple. The chrysalis is green.

Behavior

This is a butterfly of the ground layer. Its flight is weak and low, and males patrol open, low-lying areas only a few inches above the ground looking for females. Females behave very differently. Except when they are taking nectar or laying eggs, they often sit motionless deep in the vegetation, so the species is easily overlooked even where it is common.

To warm up, the Dainty Sulphur seldom spreads its wings. It rests with its wings closed and turns its body so the wings are at right angles to the sun's rays. That way the sun falls on the dark scales of the underside, which warms the flight muscles faster. Adults feed at small flowers with short corolla tubes and have also been seen on damp ground. In Florida they are commonly seen in summer along roadsides where Spanish needles grow.

Courtship was described in a 1982 study that also reported a new male display, one males use only some of the time. A later review noted that females sometimes mate with males that do not perform the display, so it is not required for mating.

The caterpillars build no shelter and feed at night.

Telling it apart

The best way to identify it is the combination of marks. It is tiny, yellow above with broad black forewing tips and a black bar along the forewing's trailing edge. Underneath, the forewing has an orange or yellow patch at the base, orange along the leading edge and black spots near the margin, and the hindwing is olive-green.

It most resembles the Barred Yellow. The Dainty Sulphur's longer, narrower forewing helps tell them apart. Its host plants are also unusual: it is the only North American sulphur whose caterpillars eat plants of the aster family, so a tiny sulphur laying eggs on Spanish needles is almost certainly this species.

To tell the sexes apart, look for the male's orange-red scent patch on the hindwing. The female is blacker above.

Male and female

Females have more black on the upperside than males and an orange-yellow flush on the hindwing, and in Caribbean specimens more orange under the forewing. Males have an orange-red scent patch inside the dark bar on the hindwing.

Habitat & cover

Habitat requirements

The Dainty Sulphur lives in open, sunny, dry places with low-growing plants. These include weedy fields, farmland, roadsides and road edges, vacant lots, utility easements, meadows, grasslands, hillsides, riverbanks, coastal flats and waste ground. In Florida it is mostly found on disturbed sites, weedy fields and roadsides, and it occurs all year, especially in the southern part of the state.

Its habitat follows its host plants. Spanish needles (Bidens alba), the main host in Florida, is native across the state and grows thickly in full sun on disturbed ground such as road medians, fields and landscaped areas. Once established it tolerates drought and adapts to many settings. Green carpetweed, another host, is often found in lawns that have been allowed to go natural. Such lawns, with small flowering plants like clover, frogfruit and violets, can supply both nectar and host plants.

Cold sets the limit. The species cannot survive long periods of freezing, so it is a permanent resident only where winters are mild. Across its wider range it also reaches high country in the West, from about 4,300 ft to 13,000 ft (1,311–3,962 m), though it is usually found below about 9,000 ft (2,743 m).

Shelter

Each life stage shelters in or on the host plant and the low vegetation around it. The caterpillars build no nest or leaf shelter and feed at night. The chrysalis usually hangs horizontally under a leaf or upright on a stem of the host plant. Adult females spend much of their time sitting still deep in the vegetation.

In the South the butterfly spends the winter as an adult, and in southern Florida and the Keys adults and caterpillars can be found all year. Farther north, apparently no stage goes dormant over winter, which is why northern populations die out each year.

Range & movements

No home range or territory has been described for this butterfly. Its movements are on a continental scale. It is a permanent resident from Guatemala north to peninsular Florida and the American Southwest, and it also lives in the Caribbean, Mexico and Central America. In Florida it is thought to have arrived from the Caribbean in the early 1900s. It flies all year in peninsular Florida, with year-round populations in the southern part of the state and the Keys, and it often colonizes northern Florida.

Because it cannot survive cold winters, it re-colonizes the north every year. By late summer it has often spread north and east across most of the continental United States. It reaches southeastern Washington, southeastern Idaho, Wyoming and Minnesota through the Great Plains, with scattered records as far as Montana, North Dakota, southern Manitoba and Ontario. In Missouri the first butterflies arrive in April and numbers build through the summer. These northward movements are one-way: the butterflies do not return south, and the northern colonies die in winter.

Sources disagree on Florida's role in these movements. One describes some Florida butterflies overwintering and then moving north in spring and summer. Another considers the southeastern populations, in Florida and Georgia, non-migratory. The species is also highly irruptive. In 2012 it appeared in unprecedented numbers well north of its normal range, but in places like New Jersey it is still considered a stray.

Threats & management

The Dainty Sulphur is not considered to need conservation action, and no specific management needs have been reported. The risks it faces come from how its weedy host plants are treated. Spanish needles is widely regarded as a weed: gardeners pull or hoe young plants and smother them with mulch, and plants on roadsides and lawns are mowed often. Each of these removes host plants and flowers. University of Florida extension advice is that Spanish needles is fine in natural areas and can be left in unkempt corners as a nectar source.

Roadsides are among this butterfly's main habitats. A federal highway review of pollinators in general, not this species, found that mowing and herbicides are the most common tools for managing roadside vegetation. It cites a Florida study in which frequent mowing kept butterfly numbers down all season, and it notes that pesticides drifting from neighboring land expose roadside pollinators. No species-specific information was found on how fire, water management or harvest affect the Dainty Sulphur.

Life history

Food habits

The Dainty Sulphur is the only North American sulphur whose caterpillars eat plants of the aster family. Most sulphurs feed on legumes instead. Its hosts are low-growing plants from several aster-family genera, most of which contain photosensitizing compounds. They include shepherd's needle (Bidens pilosa), sneezeweeds (Helenium), fetid marigold (Dyssodia) and cultivated marigolds (Tagetes), and it can be reared on marigolds. In Florida the usual host is Spanish needles (Bidens alba). Green carpetweed (Mollugo verticillata) is also used; it is an introduced weedy annual in a different family, the carpetweed family. A Florida account also lists turkey tangle frogfruit (Phyla nodiflora) as a host.

The caterpillars feed at night. The first-stage caterpillar eats only the surface tissue of the leaf, leaving a thin, translucent window. Older caterpillars eat leaves and flower petals from the edges inward.

The adults drink nectar from small flowers with short tubes. Recorded nectar plants include asters, wild marigold, rabbitbrush and Labrador tea, along with yarrow (Achillea), Spanish needles and beggarticks (Bidens), tickseed (Coreopsis), fleabane (Erigeron), frogfruit (Phyla), goldenrod (Solidago) and asters of the genus Symphyotrichum. In the Caribbean they have also been recorded on porterweed (Stachytarpheta), shepherd's needle, frogfruit and lantana, and on damp ground. In Florida, Spanish needles is a common choice for both nectar and egg-laying.

Life cycle

Males search for mates by patrolling low over open ground. Courtship can include a male display that is used only some of the time and is not needed for mating to succeed.

Females lay their eggs one at a time on seedlings of the host plant. They usually choose the upper surface of a leaf and only rarely the sepals of a flower. The egg is yellow and spindle-shaped. The caterpillar passes through four stages, called instars, feeding at night throughout, and then forms a green chrysalis under a leaf or on a stem of the host plant. In rearing studies, development from hatching through the four instars to the chrysalis took about 23 days, and the adult emerged about 15 days later, roughly 38 days after hatching in all. These times vary with temperature.

The day length a caterpillar experiences decides how the adult will look. Caterpillars raised under short days produce the darker winter form, with three times the usual dark scales on the wings.

In Florida there are three or more generations a year and the flight season lasts all year. In southern Florida and the Keys, adults and caterpillars can both be found in every month.

Conservation

The Dainty Sulphur is not listed under the Endangered Species Act. It is ranked G5, meaning demonstrably secure across its global range, though it may be quite rare at the edges of that range. It is considered common in Florida, including throughout its range in the state. No conservation action is thought necessary and no management needs have been reported. No population counts or trend data were found. Its numbers swing widely from year to year, as in the irruption of 2012, when it was seen in unprecedented numbers far north of its usual range.

Cool facts

  • It is the smallest sulphur butterfly in North America, with a wingspan of about 3/4 to 1 1/4 inches.
  • It is the only North American sulphur whose caterpillars eat plants of the aster family, such as Spanish needles.
  • Caterpillars that grow up as the days shorten become winter-form butterflies with three times the usual dark wing scales, which absorb the sun's heat better.
  • It is thought to have colonized Florida from the Caribbean in the early 1900s.
  • Males patrol only a few inches above the ground, while females often sit motionless deep in the vegetation.
  • Instead of spreading its wings to bask, it closes them and tilts them toward the sun so the dark underside scales warm its flight muscles.
  • Each summer it spreads north across much of the United States, but those northern colonies cannot survive the winter.
  • It is also known as the Dwarf Yellow.

Where to find it

Written by

  • Owner & Lead Guide

    Eric founded Viking EcoTours in 2021 after earning a B.S. in Wildlife Conservation from Virginia Tech and leading conservation crews with the Student Conservation Association.

  1. Dainty Sulphur - Alabama Butterfly Atlas (opens in a new tab), USF Water Institute / Alabama Butterfly Atlas
  2. Dainty sulphur (opens in a new tab), Florida Wildflower Foundation
  3. Dainty Sulphur (opens in a new tab), Florida Museum of Natural History
  4. White and Yellow Butterflies (opens in a new tab), UF/IFAS Gardening Solutions
  5. Dainty Sulphur Nathalis iole Boisduval, 1836 (opens in a new tab), Butterflies and Moths of North America (BAMONA)
  6. Dainty Sulphur - Montana Field Guide (opens in a new tab), Montana Natural Heritage Program / Montana FWP
  7. Dainty Sulphur (opens in a new tab), Missouri Department of Conservation
  8. Nathalis iole (opens in a new tab), UC Davis Natural Reserve System / Art Shapiro's Butterfly Site
  9. Dainty Sulphur - Natives For Your Neighborhood (opens in a new tab), Institute for Regional Conservation
  10. Dainty Sulphur (opens in a new tab), New Jersey Butterfly Club
  11. Courtship Behavior of the Dainty Sulphur Butterfly, Nathalis iole (Rutowski 1982) (opens in a new tab), Biodiversity Heritage Library / Journal of Research on the Lepidoptera
  12. Male behavior in a swallowtail butterfly (Battus philenor)... (review of courtship displays) (opens in a new tab), bioRxiv
  13. Identification of Butterflies Page 2 - Bandelier National Monument (opens in a new tab), National Park Service
  14. Nathalis iole - Dainty Sulphur (opens in a new tab), Butterflies of Cuba
  15. A native 'weed' - UF/IFAS Extension Charlotte County (opens in a new tab), UF/IFAS Extension
  16. Find Peace with the Weeds - UF/IFAS Extension Marion County (opens in a new tab), UF/IFAS Extension
  17. Bidens alba Archives - What's Happening Around Florida (opens in a new tab), UF/IFAS Extension
  18. Literature Review: Pollinator Habitat Enhancement and Best Management Practices in Highway Rights-of-Way (opens in a new tab), Federal Highway Administration
  19. Jane's Garden 10/19/14: Beggar's tick proves prolific, pesky weed (opens in a new tab), Citrus County Chronicle
  20. Nathalis iole (dainty sulphur): Identification, Facts, and Taxonomy (opens in a new tab), Bugs with Mike (Wikipedia-derived; used only for lookalike comparison, flagged for verification)
  21. What Is That Lawn Ornament? Florida's Best Wildflower?! Butterfly Needles! (opens in a new tab), Extra Mile Pest Control and Lawn Solution (commercial, low-weight)