Hawaiian Beet Webworm Moth

Spoladea recurvalis

Hawaiian Beet Webworm Moth (Spoladea recurvalis)

Photo: (c) Laura Gaudette, some rights reserved (CC BY)

  1. Home
  2. Animals
  3. Invertebrates
  4. Hawaiian Beet Webworm Moth

Spoladea recurvalis

invertebrate

Identification

Size & shape

A small, neat moth with a body about 0.4 in (10 mm) long. Seen at rest from above, it looks somewhat triangular. Wingspan figures vary from source to source. Adults are generally given as 0.75–0.94 in (19–24 mm) across, roughly the width of a thumb. Specimens from the Galápagos measured 0.67–0.83 in (17–21 mm), and moths reared in one Indian laboratory study were smaller still: males averaged 0.59 in (15.1 mm) and females 0.68 in (17.2 mm). The palps, the mouthpart feelers on the front of the head, turn upward, and the maxillary palps are long.

The caterpillar grows to about 1 in (25 mm) when mature. In the Indian rearing study, fourth-stage larvae were about 0.5 in (12.5 mm) long.

Color pattern

The adult is chocolate brown to dark gray-brown, and some describe it as buff to smoky brown. Its head, thorax and abdomen are brown, with white rings around the abdomen, and the underside of the body is light. Bold white bands cross the wings. On the forewing, a broad white middle band runs from the inner (rear) edge and ends in a hooked, "fish-hook" shape before reaching the front edge. A second broad white band runs from the front edge part of the way across the wing, with three white spots beyond it. The hindwing is dark brown with a broad, fairly straight white band whose smooth edges are outlined in black. The fringes on both wings are checkered in dark and light patches of white and brown hairs. The antennae are dark, the legs are light, and the front pair of legs is banded with brown.

A newly hatched caterpillar is creamy white and very hairy. As it grows it turns brownish green to grayish or bluish green, with a few scattered white hairs. It has a thin black line down the middle of the back, often edged with white, broad dark stripes on either side of it, and paler, yellowish sides and underside. Older larvae have a pale yellowish to yellowish-brown head covered in tiny brown spots. Just before pupating, the mature caterpillar turns reddish pink. This light pink prepupal stage lasts about three days.

Behavior

Adults are most active at night and come to lights. By day they rest under leaves, and they flush readily when someone walks through a weedy field or garden, flying off a short way when disturbed. One observer describes them as small, quick and alert, and often chased off by skippers.

The species is well known for long-distance migration and spreads on the wing. In flight-mill experiments in the laboratory, females flew longest at 63–73°F (17–23°C), and about 10 percent could still make long continuous flights at 54°F (12°C). Females flew most actively in the days before they began to lay eggs, while mating made no clear difference to flight. Adults need nectar to survive: in the same experiments, moths given no sugar solution for even a single day flew less afterward.

Newly hatched caterpillars feed on the surface tissue of the leaf underside, sometimes spinning a light web. Older larvae feed in the open or in a shelter of webbed or rolled leaves. They spin less webbing than many other webworms, and when disturbed they retreat into a tube of folded leaf.

Telling it apart

The Hawaiian beet webworm moth is the only member of its genus in North America. The species most easily confused with it is the spotted beet webworm moth, Hymenia perspectalis. Both are small buff to smoky brown moths with white wing markings. In the Hawaiian beet webworm moth, the white bands on the forewing are broad and sharp-edged, and the middle band ends in a hook before the front edge of the wing. In the spotted beet webworm moth, the bands are thinner and less sharp, and the middle band is much narrower, with no hook, ending near the middle of the wing. On the hindwing, the Hawaiian species has a fairly straight band with smooth edges, while the spotted species has a toothed band that bulges outward in the middle. Cryptobotys zoilusalis is also similar. Worn moths are hard to name, so a confident identification needs good photographs of a fresh specimen.

The caterpillars can be told apart too. In the spotted and southern beet webworms, each hair grows from a dark, raised spot. The Hawaiian beet webworm has no such spots.

Male and female

The sexes look alike in pattern. The tip of the male's abdomen is pointed, while the female's is broad and swollen, and in one laboratory study females had larger wingspans than males, 0.68 in (17.2 mm) against 0.59 in (15.1 mm).

Length
about 0.4 in (10 mm)

Habitat & cover

Habitat requirements

This moth lives in the tropics and subtropics worldwide. In the United States it occurs from Florida west to California, and in warm months it may reach as far north as New York and Illinois. It lives in open, disturbed ground: gardens, crop fields, dry meadows, roadside and waste places, and other weedy land. Weedy places matter most because they hold the larval food plants. Crop infestations tend to be worse in weedy fields, and in southern Florida in the fall, pigweeds along field margins can harbor large numbers. Weeds such as pigweed and lambsquarters serve both as alternate food plants for the caterpillars and as daytime shelter for the adults. The moth is not limited to farmland: in the Galápagos it has been collected from sea level to about 3,300 ft (1,000 m), in both pristine and human-altered habitats.

Photographed in the park, January 2020 · (c) Niki Robertson, some rights reserved (CC BY)

Shelter

Each life stage shelters on or near the food plant. Eggs are laid on the undersides of leaves, close to the midrib or the larger veins. Caterpillars hide inside rolled or folded leaves, tied into tubes with silk. Adults spend the day tucked beneath leaves of crops and weeds.

Mature caterpillars usually drop to the ground and pupate just under the soil surface, inside a cocoon coated with soil particles. Some pupate on the soil surface instead, or inside a rolled leaf, a leaf fold or plant debris, in a thin cocoon held in place by a few strands of silk.

In colder parts of the United States the species cannot survive the winter. In Virginia, for example, it has to reinvade each year.

Photographed in the park, April 2021 · (c) Robert Webster, some rights reserved (CC BY-SA)

Range & movements

No home range is known; the species is a wanderer. It is famous for long-distance migration, and adults are typically active in late summer, when they can fly long distances. In the United States most records fall between August and November, but in Florida it is reported year round. Farther north it cannot overwinter and must recolonize each season, so crop damage there comes late in the year.

It is also a migrant overseas. It reaches northwestern Europe occasionally, and has reached northeastern Europe and southeastern Canada. In Britain it is a scarce autumn migrant from the tropics, first recorded in 1951. Adults have been found in England, but larvae have not.

Flight-mill studies suggest that overwintering increased the share of males able to fly long distances, and that winds blowing toward the north cut migratory flights short. The species may also travel through the international trade in plants.

Photographed in the park, May 2021 · (c) Dennis Vollmar, some rights reserved (CC BY)

Threats & management

This moth is managed as a crop pest, mainly of amaranth, beets, chard and spinach, and in outbreak years it can wipe out a crop of Amaranthus or other hosts. Weeds are the key. Infestations are worse in weedy fields, and growers are advised not to plant next to infested crops, to remove wild amaranth and Chenopodium, to squash rolled leaves by hand, and to destroy crop debris after harvest. No treatment thresholds exist, so the advice is to watch fields and treat only if defoliation continues.

Synthetic insecticides are the most common control. They carry health and environmental risks and may lead to resistance, and the synthetic pyrethroids also kill the moth's natural enemies. Gentler options include neem, derris, pyrethrum, chili sprayed with soap, spinosad and Bt (Bacillus thuringiensis). Bt does not affect eggs and works best on small larvae.

Many parasitoids attack the larvae, including, in the United States, Cotesia marginiventris and Venturia infesta, but no program releases them in large numbers. Plant breeders have found resistance in amaranth: one variety caused 100 percent larval mortality.

The moth has also been tested as a weed-control agent against horse purslane, Trianthema portulacastrum, in potted-plant trials in the Philippines. Of the plants tested, though, it fed and completed its life cycle only on Amaranthus viridis and common purslane.

Photographed Bheema Udiya, August 2023 · (c) Ramnarayan K, some rights reserved (CC BY)

Life history

Food habits

The caterpillars eat a wide range of plants. Their favorites are in the amaranth and goosefoot group. Among crops, they eat beets, chard, spinach, and ornamental cockscomb and love-lies-bleeding. Among weeds, they eat pigweeds and other Amaranthus, lambsquarters and other goosefoots (Chenopodium), and pigweed may be preferred over cultivated hosts. Recorded host genera also include Alternanthera, Beta, Boerhavia, Celosia and Portulaca, and maize has been listed as a host. Host families range from the amaranth family to the ice plants, carrots, daisies, mustards, morning glories and legumes. In the Galápagos, larvae have been found on sea purslane (Sesuvium portulacastrum) and common purslane (Portulaca oleracea).

Young caterpillars feed on the underside of the leaf, eating the tissue but leaving the upper surface, which shows as clear "windows". Older larvae strip the foliage down to the main veins. The third larval stage is the most destructive. Adults feed on nectar, which they need to survive.

Photographed Indonesia, January 2025 · (c) Freya / Samsa, some rights reserved (CC BY-SA)

Life cycle

The moth goes through complete metamorphosis: egg, larva, pupa and adult. In the laboratory, females waited about three days after emerging before laying, then laid eggs for up to 20 days. They lay eggs singly, in rows or in small clusters on the undersides of leaves, next to the veins. Dissected gravid females held about 250 eggs on average, and mated females actually laid about 225, the same average reported from Nigeria. In the same study, females slightly outnumbered males, at 1.09 to 1.

Eggs hatched within four days in the Philippines and in 5–7 days at 65.5°F (18.6°C). Studies count five or six larval stages. Mature caterpillars turn pink and usually leave the plant to pupate in the soil, after a prepupal stage of about three days.

How long each stage lasts depends on temperature and food. One account gives about 22 days as a larva and another 12 as a prepupa and pupa. In the Philippines the pupal period was 10 days, and the whole cycle took 31–33 days. On amaranth in a Kenyan laboratory, larvae took 13.5 days and pupae 6.4 days, about 19 days in all. In India the full cycle averaged 32.7 days, stretching to 51.5 days at 64°F (18°C) and shrinking to 22.5 days at 86°F (30°C). A European summary gives under a week as an egg, three weeks as a larva and one week as a pupa. In general it takes 3–4 weeks to go from egg to adult. There are several generations a year in the warmer parts of the United States, and the generations overlap.

Photographed Dobri dol, October 2024 · (c) SteveM4560, some rights reserved (CC BY)

Conservation

The Hawaiian beet webworm moth is not listed under the Endangered Species Act and is not a species of conservation concern. In the tropics and subtropics it is treated as a crop pest. It is widespread: it has been recorded across the Pacific islands, Asia, Africa and the Americas, and more patchily in Europe.

Its range appears to be expanding. It was first recorded in Britain in 1951, and numbers there rose in 2006. In October 2024 it was recorded for the first time infesting sugar beet in western Iran, with a mean larval infestation index of 37.5 percent. No population counts or trends are available for Florida.

Photographed Smoke Rise, September 2024 · Kristi Zoebelein (iNaturalist, CC0)

Cool facts

  • Its scientific name, recurvalis, may refer to the recurved, fish-hook-shaped end of the white band on its forewing.
  • Despite its name, it is not specialized to Hawaii; it ranges across the tropics and subtropics worldwide.
  • In parts of Africa it is called the spinach moth, and in Britain the banded sable.
  • It is the only member of its genus in North America.
  • The species is famous for long-distance migration, and it has turned up as a rare autumn visitor in Britain since 1951.
  • In most of the United States it appears mainly from August to November, but in Florida it is reported year round.
  • It can go from egg to adult in about 3–4 weeks.
  • Adults depend on nectar: in laboratory tests, going without it for even a single day reduced how far they later flew.

Predators, prey & neighbors

Where to find it

Timucuan Ecological & Historic Preserve

Jul, Sep, Oct

Not on the park's official species list; reported here on iNaturalist.

  • Roads, buildings and lawns67% of sightings

    About 1,501 acres in the park

From 3 research-grade iNaturalist sightings in the park, placed on the NPS vegetation map (2012).

Everglades National Park

Jan, Mar, Jul, Sep, Nov

Not on the park's official species list; reported here on iNaturalist.

  • Roads, buildings and lawns20% of sightings

    About 2,619 acres in the park

  • Mangrove swamp20% of sightings

    About 159,692 acres in the park

  • Rivers, bays, lakes and ponds20% of sightings

    About 153,502 acres in the park

  • Salt marsh and salt flats13% of sightings

    About 13,738 acres in the park

  • Sawgrass marsh13% of sightings

    About 284,450 acres in the park

From 15 research-grade iNaturalist sightings in the park, placed on the NPS vegetation map (2009).

Photos

  • Photographed in the park, September 2019
  • Photographed in the park, January 2020
  • Photographed in the park, April 2021
  • Photographed in the park, May 2021
  • Photographed Bheema Udiya, August 2023
  • Photographed Indonesia, January 2025
  • Photographed Dobri dol, October 2024
  • Photographed Smoke Rise, September 2024
  • Photographed Near Longwood, February 2020
  • Photographed Udumbanchola, June 2022

  1. What it eats and what eats it: GloBI (opens in a new tab), Global Biotic Interactions (2026)
  2. Species Spoladea recurvalis - Beet Webworm Moth - Hodges#5170 (opens in a new tab), BugGuide.Net
  3. Hawaiian Beet Webworm Moth - Spoladea recurvalis (photo record) (opens in a new tab), BugGuide.Net
  4. Pest Of The Month: Beet Webworms (opens in a new tab), Growing Produce
  5. Beet webworm (345) - Pacific Pests, Pathogens and Weeds (opens in a new tab), Pacific Community / Lucid Apps
  6. Fact sheet - Beet webworm (345) (opens in a new tab), Pacific Community / Lucid Apps
  7. Fact sheet - Beet webworm (345) (opens in a new tab), Pacific Community / Lucid Apps
  8. Moths of North Carolina: Spoladea recurvalis (opens in a new tab), NC State Parks / NC Biodiversity Project
  9. Hawaiian Beet Webworm Moth (opens in a new tab), NC State Parks
  10. Moth Photographers Group: 5170 Spoladea recurvalis (opens in a new tab), Mississippi State University
  11. Lepidoptera Mundi: Spoladea recurvalis (opens in a new tab), Lepidoptera.eu
  12. Beet Webworm (ENTO-443) (opens in a new tab), Virginia Cooperative Extension
  13. Expression of Resistance in Amaranthus spp.: Effects of Selected Accessions on the Behaviour and Biology of the Amaranth Leaf-Webber, Spoladea recurvalis (opens in a new tab), Insects (MDPI) via PMC
  14. Flight activity, reproduction, and adult nutrition of the beet webworm, Spoladea recurvalis (opens in a new tab), Applied Entomology and Zoology (J-STAGE)
  15. Flight activity, reproduction, and adult nutrition of the beet webworm (full text page) (opens in a new tab), ResearchGate
  16. Seasonal abundance of amaranth lepidopteran (opens in a new tab), Kenyatta University
  17. Efficacy of Spoladea recurvalis as biological control agent against the weed Trianthema portulacastrum L. (opens in a new tab), FAO AGRIS
  18. Effects of temperature on the duration of the life cycle of Hymenia (Spoladea) recurvalis (opens in a new tab), Connect Journals
  19. Spoladea recurvalis - Catalogue of the Lepidoptera of Belgium (opens in a new tab), Belgian Biodiversity Platform
  20. Management of Spoladea recurvalis on amaranths using biopesticides (opens in a new tab), Afribary (thesis repository)
  21. Spoladea recurvalis (Fabricius 1775) - Galápagos Lepidoptera treatment (opens in a new tab), GBIF
  22. Spoladea recurvalis Fabricius 1775 (opens in a new tab), Zenodo (Galápagos moths treatment)
  23. Spoladea recurvalis (Ukraine record) (opens in a new tab), Zenodo
  24. Spoladea recurvalis (Fabricius, 1775) (opens in a new tab), GBIF
  25. Spoladea recurvalis Fabricius, 1775 (opens in a new tab), India Biodiversity Portal
  26. Hantsmoths - 63.047 Spoladea recurvalis (opens in a new tab), Hampshire Moth Group
  27. Banded Sable Spoladea recurvalis (opens in a new tab), UKMoths
  28. First record of the Hawaiian beet webworm infesting sugar beet in Lorestan Province, Iran (opens in a new tab), Springer (Phytoparasitica/Int. J. Tropical Insect Science)
  29. Herpetogramma bipunctalis / Hawaiian beet webworm - Vegetable Pests (opens in a new tab), Grovida
  30. Nature in the Ozarks: Hawaiian Beet Webworm Moth (opens in a new tab), Nature in the Ozarks blog