Northern Cloudywing
Cecropterus pylades
- Home
- Animals
- Invertebrates
- Northern Cloudywing
Cecropterus pylades
Identification
Size & shape
The Northern Cloudywing is a medium-sized, dark skipper. Its wingspan is given as 1.1–1.9 in (2.8–4.7 cm) across sources, with most putting it at about 1¼–1¾ in (3.2–4.4 cm). It runs slightly larger than its two close relatives, the Southern and Confused Cloudywings. The wings are broad, and the hindwing tapers slightly toward the bottom. Like other spread-wing skippers, it often rests with its forewings and hindwings stretched out to the sides.
The chrysalis is brown or greenish brown, with a brown head, dark lines between the abdominal segments and lighter wing cases.
Color pattern
The upperside is plain dark brown. On the outer half of each forewing there are small, whitish, glassy (hyaline) spots. The spots are triangular and irregular rather than lined up: three or four small, misaligned spots near the wingtip, several near the middle of the leading edge, and one or two tiny spots in the centre of the wing. Some describe them as two groups touching the leading edge plus a triangle of three spots in the middle. The wing fringes are checkered. On fresh butterflies they are pale tan or buffy brown checked with darker brown or black, and the outer edge of the hindwing looks frosted. The palps, which form the "face", are dark, and the antennae are dark near the bend.
The underside is brown with gray overscaling and paler frosting along the margins. It shades outward from dark brown near the body to hoary gray at the edges, and is paler toward the rear of the hindwing. The hindwing underside carries two dark bands, a darker median band and a spiky band beyond it, and the forewing spots show through on the underside.
The egg is light green to white. Descriptions of the caterpillar vary. One calls it green, with a darker line along the back, two pinkish lines along the sides and a black head. Another calls it dark green, with a dark brownish line along the back, paler side lines and a dark brown head. A Florida description calls it greenish brown, with a black head and many light-colored hairs.
Behavior
The flight is low, fast and erratic. Adults dart along dirt roads and through clearings, stopping often to take nectar, and they regularly feed at flowers in partly wooded places but rarely in built-up areas. They usually rest with their wings spread flat, though observers in the far west note that they often sit with the wings only partly open.
Males hold territories. A male perches near the ground, on top of tall grasses or small shrubs, or on trees and shrubs, and may use the same perch for several days. From there he darts out at passing rival males, at females to court them, and at almost anything flying by that looks remotely like a female. Males have been called fierce: if another male or a different insect challenges them, they chase it and try to attack.
Numbers of them can gather at muddy roadsides and creek beds to drink, although in some western populations it is said not to puddle much. Accounts differ on how social it is. In some regions it is usually seen singly and is not common, while in the Maritime provinces of Canada it is described as highly colonial and often locally common.
The caterpillars feed at night and spend the day in shelters of leaves tied together with silk. A caterpillar forcibly flicks its droppings away so they land far from the nest.
Telling it apart
The Northern, Southern and Confused Cloudywings often fly together, and one guide calls them an identification nightmare. Not every cloudywing can be identified in the field.
Compared with the Southern Cloudywing, the Northern has three useful marks. First, its white forewing spots are smaller, and none is shaped like an hourglass. The Southern's spots line up, and the largest is hourglass-shaped. Second, the Northern has a dusky, dark face with only a thin, broken white line over the eye. The Southern has a pale, silvery-gray face with a bold white line over the eye. Third, the Northern lacks the pale patch the Southern shows at the bend of the antenna. One guide advises treating an identification as tentative unless all three marks agree. The Southern's spring brood is fainter than its later broods and looks more like the other two species.
Compared with the Confused Cloudywing, the Northern is dark-faced, seldom shows a pale eye ring and is darker along the outer margins of the underwing. The Confused has a pale face and narrow, bar-like forewing spots, and the bottom white spot of its outer row is set off from the rest.
On males there is one definitive mark: the Northern is the only cloudywing with a costal fold, a folded-over leading edge on the upper forewing that holds scent scales. Southern and Confused males lack it.
Duskywings can also be confused with cloudywings. A cloudywing is evenly dark brown above, with a row of angular white spots, and has two loose dark bands under the hindwing. The Dreamy Duskywing is smaller and has no white spots on the forewing.
Male and female
Males have a costal fold on the leading edge of the forewing that holds scent scales; females do not. Males perch, defend territories and chase passing butterflies, while females lay the eggs one at a time.
Habitat & cover
Habitat requirements
The Northern Cloudywing is an adaptable generalist of open woods and edges, not a wetland species. It uses roadsides, open woodlands, forest clearings and margins, old fields, utility rights-of-way, brushy places and gardens. In Florida it is found in scrub and along forest edges. In the Southeast it also occurs in dry pine woods, glades, mesic deciduous woods and pine and scrub-oak sandhills. It prefers dry to moderately moist sites in partial sun, and of the three cloudywings it is the one most likely to be found in the woods.
Its main requirement is its larval host plants, which are legumes. The adults stay fairly close to them, so suitable habitat must have host legumes nearby, along with flowers for nectar such as milkweeds, thistles and dogbane.
Shelter
The caterpillar shelters in a nest it builds on the host plant by folding or tying leaves together with silk. Early on the nest uses two leaves; in later stages it uses three or four. Accounts differ on where the caterpillar spends the winter. Some say the full-grown caterpillar hibernates in its last leaf nest. Others say the mature caterpillars of the final generation leave the host plant and hibernate in the leaf litter. In spring it pupates inside a leaf shelter. Adult males spend much of their time on perches near the ground, on grass tops or on small shrubs.
Range & movements
No home-range size has been measured. Males are territorial and may keep the same perch for several days. The species is a resident, and no migration has been reported.
Its range runs from Nova Scotia west across southern Canada to British Columbia, and south through the western and Rocky Mountain states to Mexico, Texas, the Gulf states and Florida. Genomic work published in 2023 separated the Rocky Mountain and southwestern populations into species of their own. In Florida it reaches southern peninsular Florida but is rare in the southernmost part of the peninsula.
In Florida, adults fly from March to November, or into December in the south.
Threats & management
Fire can wipe out a local colony, but the species can recover. In California, a fire eliminated the butterfly from its only known breeding site there, and it later recolonized the site from nearby. The caterpillars readily use introduced legumes, including red clover, white clover, alfalfa, bird's-foot trefoil, introduced vetches and Chinese bush clover. That helps the species persist on roadsides, in fields and on rights-of-way. No special management needs have been reported, and conservation action is not usually required, though some regions say its population trends need better monitoring.
Life history
Food habits
The caterpillars eat only herbaceous plants of the legume family, feeding on the leaves at night. Recorded hosts include beggar's ticks or tick-trefoils (Desmodium), bush clovers (Lespedeza), clovers (Trifolium), Hosackia, hog peanut (Amphicarpaea), Clitoria mariana, Strophostyles helvola and Phaseolus polystachios. Introduced legumes are also used, among them red clover, white clover, alfalfa, bird's-foot trefoil, introduced vetches and Chinese bush clover (Lespedeza cuneata). The hosts reported in Florida are groundnut (Apios americana), spurred butterfly-pea (Centrosema virginianum), Elliott's milkpea (Galactia elliottii), eastern milkpea (Galactia regularis) and Florida hoarypea (Tephrosia florida).
The adults take nectar, mostly from blue, purple, pink or white flowers. Recorded nectar plants include dogbane, selfheal, crown vetch, Japanese honeysuckle, thistles, common milkweed, Deptford pink, hoary vervain, vetches and pale purple coneflower. The adults also drink moisture at muddy spots.
Life cycle
Males perch and wait for females, then chase and court them as they pass. The male's costal fold holds scent scales that release pheromones. Females lay their eggs one at a time on the undersides of host-plant leaves.
The eggs hatch in 5–8 days, depending on temperature. The caterpillar passes through five stages (instars), taking about 25–39 days to reach the fifth, and spends about 28–31 days in that final stage. It spends the winter as a full-grown fifth-stage caterpillar, in its leaf nest or in the leaf litter. In spring it pupates inside a leaf shelter, which takes 7–10 days, and the adult emerges after 12–14 days.
How many generations it has depends on climate. In the north there is a single brood, flying from May to July, sometimes with a partial second generation in August. In the south it flies earlier, and Texas has two broods between March and September. In Georgia there can be up to three broods, and on the Coastal Plain adults fly from mid-March to mid-April and again from July to September. In Florida, adults fly from March to November, or into December in the south.
Conservation
The Northern Cloudywing is not listed under the Endangered Species Act. NatureServe ranks it G5, demonstrably secure across its range. States rank it secure or apparently secure, for example S5 in North Carolina, Massachusetts and Montana and S4 in Idaho. It is described as common and widespread but rarely abundant, and a butterfly atlas in Connecticut found no change in its status. No Florida rank or population figures were found.
Cool facts
- Male Northern Cloudywings are the only cloudywings with a costal fold, a folded-over flap on the edge of the forewing that holds perfume scales.
- The caterpillars forcibly flick their droppings so they land well away from their leaf nest.
- It spends the winter as a full-grown caterpillar and turns into a chrysalis only in spring.
- Butterfly guides call the three look-alike cloudywings an identification nightmare, and they often fly together.
- Males are fierce defenders of their perches and chase rival males and even other kinds of insects.
- Numbers of them can gather to drink at muddy roadsides and creek beds.
- In 2023, genomic work split western populations into separate species.
Where to find it
Canaveral National Seashore
Mar
Not on the park's official species list; reported here on iNaturalist.
- Pine flatwoods67% of sightings
About 2,592 acres in the park
From 3 research-grade iNaturalist sightings in the park, placed on the NPS vegetation map (2012).
- Northern Cloudywing Thorybes pylades (Scudder, 1870) (opens in a new tab), Butterflies and Moths of North America
- Northern Cloudywing - Alabama Butterfly Atlas (opens in a new tab), Alabama Butterfly Atlas
- Northern Cloudywing (opens in a new tab), Missouri Department of Conservation
- Northern Cloudywing - Montana Field Guide (opens in a new tab), Montana Natural Heritage Program
- Natives for Your Neighborhood - Northern Cloudywing (opens in a new tab), Institute for Regional Conservation
- WEC 22/UW057: Butterfly Gardening in Florida (opens in a new tab), UF/IFAS Extension
- Northern Cloudywing (opens in a new tab), Toronto Entomologists' Association (Butterflies of Canada)
- Butterflies of North Carolina - Northern Cloudywing (opens in a new tab), NC Division of Parks and Recreation
- Confused Cloudywing (opens in a new tab), NC Division of Parks and Recreation
- Thorybes pylades (opens in a new tab), UC Davis Natural Reserve System / Butterflies of California
- Northern Cloudywing (opens in a new tab), Vermont Butterfly Atlas (VCE)
- Southern Cloudywing (opens in a new tab), Vermont Butterfly Atlas (VCE)
- Northern Cloudywing (opens in a new tab), NABA New Jersey chapter
- Southern Cloudywing - Alabama Butterfly Atlas (opens in a new tab), Alabama Butterfly Atlas
- Confused Cloudywing - Alabama Butterfly Atlas (opens in a new tab), Alabama Butterfly Atlas
- Confused Cloudywing Thorybes confusis Bell, 1922 (opens in a new tab), Butterflies and Moths of North America
- Find a Butterfly - Southern Cloudywing (opens in a new tab), Mass Audubon
- Northern Cloudywing (opens in a new tab), Butterflies of Massachusetts
- Northern Cloudywing — wisconsinbutterflies.org (opens in a new tab), Wisconsin Butterfly Atlas
- Thorybes pylades (Northern Cloudy Wing Skipper) (opens in a new tab), Idaho Department of Fish & Game
- Northern Cloudywing Thorybes pylades — Pierre Howard's Butterflies of Georgia (opens in a new tab), Georgia Nature
- Species Page: Northern Cloudywing (Thorybes pylades) (opens in a new tab), Nebraska Lepidoptera
- Northern Cloudywing (Thorybes pylades) (opens in a new tab), Atlantic Canada Conservation Data Centre (Maritime Butterfly Atlas)
- Northern Cloudywing (opens in a new tab), Butterflies of Oregon
- Butterflies of New Mexico: The Skippers I (opens in a new tab), PEEC Nature
- Cecropterus indistinctus - Northern Cloudywing (opens in a new tab), SoCal Butterflies
- northern cloudywing (opens in a new tab), Sky Meadows State Park nature guide
- We Butterfly - Northern Cloudywing (opens in a new tab), Western Butterfly Network
- Regional Species Checklists - Alachua County, Florida (opens in a new tab), Butterflies and Moths of North America
- Regional Species Checklists - Miami-Dade County, Florida (opens in a new tab), Butterflies and Moths of North America
- Northern Cloudywing (opens in a new tab), Butterfly Species Galleries
- Thorybes pylades (opens in a new tab), Prairie Haven
