Sleepy Duskywing
Erynnis brizo
- Home
- Animals
- Invertebrates
- Sleepy Duskywing
Erynnis brizo · Hesperiidae, Lepidoptera
Identification
Size & shape
A small, dark, compact skipper with a stout body, broad wings and blunt clubs on the antennae. Published wingspans run from about 1 1/8 to 1 3/4 in (28–45 mm), a little less than the length of a thumb. Sources disagree on where it falls among its relatives: one calls it a larger duskywing, another very small, at about 1.35 in (3.4 cm), between the Dreamy and Juvenal's Duskywings in size. Beside the Dreamy Duskywing it is the larger of the two.
The proportions help with close views. The antennae are short, roughly a third the length of the forewing's leading edge, against about half in the Dreamy Duskywing. The wings look short for the body. The palps, the scaly mouthparts that jut forward below the eyes, are shorter than the Dreamy's, though this is not always easy to see.
Color pattern
The upperside is dark brown to blackish-brown with no glassy or translucent spots, and no whitish spots near the forewing tip. Two wide bands cross each forewing. They are gray to purplish-gray, edged in dark, and are often described as chainlike. The outer band is usually zigzag, or so broken that it looks like a row of segments. The inner band is less distinct. Pale frosting edges the forewing tip and leading edge, and the darker parts carry black lines, grayish patches and small cream-colored spots.
Males have blackish-brown forewings with a distinct dark-gray chain across the outer wing. Females are browner, so their chain marks stand out more, and the pale brown patch on the leading edge between the two chains is frosted to varying degrees. The hindwing is blackish-brown in males and brown in females, with a row of small pale spots along the edge and more pale spots scattered over the outer half. The underside is dark brown, with many small pale spots that mirror the pattern above.
In Florida adults fly from January to May, so most are fresh in late winter and early spring. Fresh wings show the gray bands and frosting best.
Behavior
The Sleepy Duskywing flies fast and close to the ground with a bouncing flight. It lands on bare soil or low plants with its wings held open and flat, in the typical duskywing pose. It keeps its wings open while resting, perching and taking nectar. It flies in shrubby places and in openings in oak woods and barrens, and seldom strays far from shade.
To find females, males perch in clearings and on hilltops throughout the day. Where many males share an area, they patrol around the host oaks instead. A perched male sits on a twig, darts out to check anything that flies past, and usually comes back to the same twig, so a visitor can often wait for one to return.
Adults visit flowers in oak woods and drink at damp soil, mud and puddles, where they take up moisture and nutrients. They also rest on the ground. In the Southeast they gather in mixed groups at wet spots, and Juvenal's Duskywings usually outnumber Sleepys in the larger groups. This is one of the earliest skippers of the year. In Alabama it is flying by February.
Telling it apart
Look first for glassy spots on the forewing. Juvenal's, Horace's and Wild Indigo Duskywings all have these translucent spots, and the Sleepy has none. Among the duskywings, only the Dreamy Duskywing also lacks them. Juvenal's Duskywing flies early in the season too and is the more common look-alike in the Southeast, so a duskywing seen in late winter in Florida's oak scrub is worth checking for the missing glassy spots.
Telling it from the Dreamy Duskywing takes several marks. The Sleepy has two distinct, continuous dark bands across the forewing, heavier and more even than the Dreamy's jumbled, narrower chain pattern. It has less gray scaling on the forewing, and in particular a less well-defined silvery patch at the bend of the wing. It also lacks the Dreamy's small white dot on the forewing. Its palps stick out less, its antennae are shorter for the size of its wing, and it is the larger butterfly.
Season and food plant help as well. The Sleepy comes out earlier, so it is usually worn by the time the Dreamy peaks. Its caterpillars eat oaks, while Dreamy caterpillars eat willows and aspens, so the two are seldom found together.
Male and female
Males are blackish-brown, and their forewing carries a fold with yellow scent scales. Females are browner, so their gray chain marks stand out more, their hindwings are brown rather than blackish, and they carry a patch of scent scales on the seventh abdominal segment.
Habitat & cover
Habitat requirements
The Sleepy Duskywing is a butterfly of shrubby oaks on dry, poor soils. Across its range it lives in oak scrub, oak-pine scrub, chaparral and barrens on well-drained sandy or shaly ground: places with thin, dry soils where scrub oaks thrive. In Florida and Alabama the recorded habitats are scrub oak communities, dry oak woodlands, sandhills, dry flatwoods and other uplands. Dry woodlands, forest margins and nearby open areas are also listed.
The species is very particular about where it lives, much more so than the Dreamy Duskywing. It is found only in the right habitat, and that habitat depends on its host oaks. Within it, adults use two kinds of ground. They fly in shrubby areas, openings and woodland edges, but rarely far from shade. They also feed at the flowers of nearby open ground. Farther north, for example, they keep to dry oak woods, often near dry prairie openings where they take nectar.
Habitat is lost when the oaks are. Scrub-oak barrens left unburned grow into other kinds of vegetation, and with them the butterfly disappears.
Shelter
The caterpillar builds its own shelter. It rolls or ties host-oak leaves together with silk and lives inside, coming out to feed. Most of its life is spent in this shelter. A fully grown caterpillar overwinters in its rolled-leaf nest without eating again, and pupates in early spring inside a silk-lined leaf roll. The species is one of the few oak-feeding butterflies and moths that spend the winter as caterpillars. Duskywing leaf tents can be seen on oaks.
Adults stay close to shade. They perch on twigs in and around clearings and rest on bare ground or low plants.
Range & movements
The Sleepy Duskywing has a wide range in two parts. In the west it occurs from California east to Utah and southern Wyoming, and south through the mountains to Arizona, New Mexico, Baja California Norte and central Mexico. In the east it ranges from Manitoba south through southern Ontario and the eastern United States to central Florida, the Gulf Coast and central Texas. Four subspecies are named, and only the nominate form, brizo, occurs in Canada.
Daily movements center on the host oaks. Males hold perches in clearings and on hilltops, or patrol around host plants when many are about. Butterflies generally stay fairly close to their larval food plants. No figures for home-range size, migration or dispersal distance were found.
Threats & management
The main threat is the loss or decline of the scrub oak habitat the species depends on. Studies from the northern part of the range describe how that happens. Wildfire once favored fire-resistant pitch pine and scrub oak. When fire is kept out, other trees move in and outcompete them, and the barrens turn into other vegetation. Maine rates fire suppression a high-severity threat to the species. It also lists ongoing development and habitat fragmentation, and rates roads and railroads a moderate threat.
Scrub oak is adapted to fire and recovers quickly even after a hot crown fire. Barrens on conservation land are now kept open with prescribed burning, along with mechanical treatment and mowing of scrub oak where burning is impractical. A study of scrub oak barrens in Pennsylvania recommended managing for a mosaic of stages of regrowth after disturbance to support the diversity of butterflies and moths.
Over the species as a whole, conservation action is not usually needed, and no management needs are reported. No information specific to Florida on fire, pesticides or water management was found.
Life history
Food habits
The caterpillars eat oak leaves, mostly from shrubby oaks. They feed from a shelter of leaves sewn together with silk. In Florida the reported hosts are Chapman's oak (Quercus chapmanii), the Florida scrub oak Quercus inopina, turkey oak (Q. laevis) and myrtle oak (Q. myrtifolia). Black oak (Q. velutina) is documented in Alabama.
Elsewhere the listed hosts include the northern scrub oak (Q. ilicifolia), blackjack oak (Q. marilandica), and possibly young plants of other oaks. Bur oak is the only host used in Manitoba, and American chestnut is also listed. Females lay on young leaves and leaf buds, which the young caterpillars eat.
Adults drink nectar from early-spring flowers. Recorded sources include heaths such as wild azalea and blueberry, as well as blackberry, dewberry, cherry, native plums, eastern redbud, downy phlox, hoary puccoon, cinquefoils, hawkweed and dandelion. An early naturalist, Scudder, wrote that the female is "very fond of violet blossoms." Redbud, blueberries and native plums are recommended for gardeners who want to feed this early-flying skipper. Adults also drink fluids from mud, puddles and other wet places.
Life cycle
The Sleepy Duskywing has only one generation a year throughout its range, even in the south, which may limit how common it becomes. Adults fly from January to May in Florida and Texas, and from March to June elsewhere. In Alabama the flight is mostly in March and April.
Males find females by perching in clearings and on hilltops, or by patrolling host oaks. Both sexes carry scent scales: the male in a fold along the leading edge of the forewing, which holds yellow scent scales, and the female in a patch on the seventh segment of the abdomen.
Females lay eggs one at a time on young leaves or leaf buds of the host oak. The egg is pale green and dome-shaped, with 15 prominent vertical ribs, and hatches in about 8 days. The caterpillar is stout and tapers at both ends. It is pale green, with a darker stripe down the back edged in white or yellow, paler stripes on the sides, and sometimes a purplish tinge at the front and rear. The head is yellowish to dark brown, with one or more orange-yellow spots. The caterpillar lives in a leaf nest and grows slowly through summer and fall.
The caterpillar is fully grown before winter. In one subspecies it is recorded hibernating as a mature fifth-instar caterpillar. It overwinters without feeding and does not eat again after hibernation. In early spring it pupates in a silk-lined leaf roll. The pupal stage lasts 2–3 weeks, and then the adult emerges. No stage durations specific to Florida were found.
Conservation
The Sleepy Duskywing is not listed under the federal Endangered Species Act. Its global rank is G5, demonstrably secure, though it can be quite rare in parts of its range, especially at the edges. Conservation action is not usually considered necessary over the range as a whole.
Locally the picture differs. Maine has listed it as state Threatened since 2007 and ranks it S2 there, because it has a limited distribution and depends on rare habitat in a fast-developing area. The state's planned action is to complete a statewide butterfly atlas. In New Jersey, Special Concern status was recommended in 2015, though no formal rule has been filed. The main threat there is the loss or decline of scrub oak and pitch pine barrens. Being a southern butterfly, it may spread north with a warming climate if enough habitat remains. In Iowa it is a rare breeding resident, and in Canada it is uncommon throughout its range, found only in exactly the right habitat.
How much habitat has been lost shows in Pennsylvania. Scrub oak barrens there shrank from more than 2,000,000 acres (809,000 ha) in the mid-1900s to about 17,600 acres (7,132 ha) by the late 1900s. No status or trend figures specific to Florida were found.
Cool facts
- In Florida the Sleepy Duskywing flies from January to May, and it is one of the earliest skippers of the year in the Southeast.
- Butterfly watchers call it a harbinger of spring, the species that opens their butterfly season.
- Its caterpillars spend the winter fully grown, rolled up in a silk-tied oak-leaf shelter, and do not eat again before pupating in spring.
- A male perches on a twig, darts out at anything that flies past, and usually returns to the same twig.
- It has just one generation a year even in the warm south, which may limit how common it gets.
- In Florida its caterpillars eat scrub oaks such as myrtle oak, Chapman's oak and turkey oak.
- Males were first illustrated by John Abbot, who collected and painted insects in Virginia from 1773 to 1776 and in Georgia from 1776 to 1792.
- It is also known as the Banded Oak Duskywing, after the two bands across its forewings.
Where to find it
Canaveral National Seashore
Mar
Not on the park's official species list; reported here on iNaturalist.
- Oak–palmetto scrub89% of sightings
About 2,812 acres in the park
From 9 research-grade iNaturalist sightings in the park, placed on the NPS vegetation map (2012).
- Sleepy Duskywing Erynnis brizo (opens in a new tab), Butterflies and Moths of North America (BAMONA)
- Species Erynnis brizo - Sleepy Duskywing - Hodges#3946 (opens in a new tab), BugGuide (Iowa State University)
- Sleepy Duskywing Erynnis brizo (Alabama Butterfly Atlas) (opens in a new tab), Butterfly Atlas, University of South Florida / Alabama
- WEC 22/UW057: Butterfly Gardening in Florida (opens in a new tab), UF/IFAS Extension
- Find a Butterfly: Sleepy Duskywing (opens in a new tab), Mass Audubon
- Sleepy Duskywing (opens in a new tab), New Jersey Butterfly Club
- Sleepy Duskywing - Erynnis brizo (opens in a new tab), Toronto Entomologists' Association
- Sleepy Duskywing (Erynnis brizo) (opens in a new tab), Tennessee Valley NABA
- Sleepy Duskywing (Erynnis brizo) - Insects of Iowa (opens in a new tab), Insects of Iowa
- Sleepy Duskywing - Conserve Wildlife Foundation of NJ (opens in a new tab), Conserve Wildlife Foundation of New Jersey
- Sleepy Duskywing - Erynnis brizo (Maine 2025 Wildlife Action Plan SGCN) (opens in a new tab), Maine Department of Inland Fisheries and Wildlife
- Maine DIFW 2019-20 report (threatened species, pine barrens) (opens in a new tab), Maine Department of Inland Fisheries and Wildlife
- Fire Management Plan for Ossipee Pine Barrens Preserve, Second Edition (opens in a new tab), The Nature Conservancy
- Sleepy Duskywing - Butterflies of Massachusetts (opens in a new tab), Butterflies of Massachusetts
- Confoundingly Confusing Duskywings (opens in a new tab), George DeWolf, Baker Ponds Butterfly Count
- Illustrated Guide to the Immature Lepidoptera on Oaks (opens in a new tab), USDA Forest Service Forest Health
- Erynnis brizo burgessi - Raising Butterflies (opens in a new tab), Raising Butterflies
- A Comparison of Lepidoptera Communities Inhabiting Restored and Late Successional Pitch Pine—Scrub Oak Barrens in Pennsylvania (opens in a new tab), AGRIS / FAO
- Sleepy Duskywing (NatureWorks) (opens in a new tab), New Hampshire PBS (conflicting on diet/broods; not relied on)
