Southern Live Oak Stem Gall Wasp

Callirhytis quercusbatatoides

Southern Live Oak Stem Gall Wasp (Callirhytis quercusbatatoides)

Photo: (c) Victor Engel, some rights reserved (CC BY)

  1. Home
  2. Animals
  3. Invertebrates
  4. Southern Live Oak Stem Gall Wasp

Callirhytis quercusbatatoides

invertebrate

Identification

Size & shape

The adult is a tiny wasp. Gall wasps of its family, this species included, are about 0.08–0.12 in (2–3 mm) long. What a visitor actually sees is the gall the wasp's young grow in, not the insect.

The gall is an abrupt, globular, thick-walled swelling that is part of the stem itself. It forms on the new growth of live oak twigs and branches and is roughly ellipsoid in shape. Inside it is divided into many chambers, each holding one developing wasp. Describing the gall in 1881, William Ashmead called it potato-like and said it varied in size and form. He gave lengths of 0.4–0.7 in (10–18 mm), sometimes up to an inch (25 mm), and widths of 0.3 to half an inch (8–13 mm) or more. He found no separate hard kernels inside. Each insect was separated from the next by a very thin, parchment-like wall, and he counted fifteen gall wasps in a single gall.

A modern sample of 1,440 galls from 33 trees measured 0.26–1.94 in (6.66–49.29 mm) long, with an average of about 0.67 in (16.96 mm). Size matters to the wasps: when 101 galls were cut open, the larger ones had more chambers and so held more offspring.

Color pattern

The gall changes color as it ages. Ashmead described its outer surface as rough and the same color as the bark, with a white inside about as firm as a potato. A newly formed gall is a bright silver or gray, stiff and bumpy, with no exit holes and no peck marks. Galls stay on the tree for years, and the older ones turn darker and pick up mold and lichens. By then they usually show the round holes the adults chewed to get out, along with damage from predators. The sources do not describe the adult wasp's own coloring.

Behavior

Almost all of this wasp's life happens out of sight, inside the gall. The larvae grow in separate chambers in the swollen stem. In the genus Callirhytis, the grubs have chewing mouthparts but apparently don't chew the plant. Instead they lap up nutrients that the gall tissue gives off. Adults are poor fliers.

What a visitor notices are the gray, lumpy galls on young live oak stems. Fresh silver-gray galls often sit beside darker, older ones on the same tree, because galls stay on the branches for several years. Old and new galls are used differently, too: the old ones are riddled with exit holes, while the fresh ones are still occupied. In one Texas record from early April, cutting galls open showed that some adults had already left while others were still inside.

Birds are the galls' main visible enemy. In a study of urban live oaks, the only damage on the galls was beak damage, and observers confirmed it by watching birds attack them. The researchers named woodpeckers among the insect-eating birds that prey on the galls.

Telling it apart

Live oaks carry at least six, and possibly as many as twelve, species of gall wasps, so this is not the only gall on these trees. Field guides tell the species apart by their galls, and the sources give no way to separate the adult wasps mark by mark.

This species makes a hard, many-chambered, potato-like swelling built into new twigs and branches. It starts silver-gray and darkens with age. The crypt gall wasp, Bassettia pallida, also makes galls in the stems of live oak and sand live oak. A different live oak gall wasp, Andricus quercusfoliatus, makes something quite unlike a stem swelling: a leafy, green, modified acorn cap. An expert separated the brown stem galls on the same Louisiana oaks as this species.

Other woody, many-chambered stem galls belong to related Callirhytis species, such as the gouty oak gall and the horned oak gall. These grow on red and black oaks, not live oaks. The horned oak gall grows horns in its second or third year and can reach 2 in (5 cm) across. Florida's spined or horned oak galls grow on laurel oak and similar trees, and their young galls are smooth and greenish brown. A gray, horn-free swelling on a live oak twig points to this species.

Male and female

Only the all-female generation is known: its wasps are females that reproduce without mating. Males would belong to the other generation, with both sexes, which has never been found.

Length
0.08–0.12 in (2–3 mm)

Habitat & cover

Habitat requirements

This wasp lives wherever its host oaks grow. Its main host is the southern live oak, Quercus virginiana, and it is also recorded on sand live oak, Quercus geminata, Texas live oak, Quercus fusiformis, and dwarf live oak, Quercus minima. The galls form only on newly growing stems, so a tree has to be putting out fresh shoots for the wasp to use it.

It does not need wild land. One major study of the species was carried out on live oaks planted in a city medical district. A Louisiana landowner found the galls concentrated on young live oak saplings, about four years old, growing in sunny meadows, with a few on mature trees. That is one observer's account rather than a measured study.

The two main hosts differ in a way that matters to the wasp. Southern live oak produces new flowers and leaves about three weeks earlier in spring, on average, than sand live oak. The sources do not say what soils, water or patch sizes the species needs.

Shelter

The gall is the wasp's shelter for its whole immature life. Each larva lives in its own chamber inside the woody swelling, protected by thick walls, and develops through to adulthood there. It leaves only when grown, chewing an exit hole on the way out. The galls also carry the wasps through winter. Galls collected from southern live oak in northeast Florida in mid-December produced adults the following March. Empty galls stay on the tree for several years after the wasps have gone.

Range & movements

Adults fly poorly, and gall-formers like this one tend to occur in patches within a host population: plenty on some trees, few or none on others. The sources record no home ranges, migration or dispersal distances.

Ashmead first described the species from Florida in 1881. It has since been recorded in Texas, Louisiana and North Carolina, where it was found on sand live oak. Observers have reported it from coastal North Carolina south to the tip of the Florida peninsula, west to West Texas and into northeastern Mexico. In Florida, galls on live oak have been reported as late as March.

Threats & management

Birds are the main pressure studied on this species. Birds attack the large galls heavily. When birds were kept off 11 large host trees for five years, the galls grew 12.3 percent larger than on trees birds could reach, averaging about 0.77 in (19.56 mm) against 0.69 in (17.42 mm). The researchers tie changes to habitat to changes in the density of insect-eating birds, especially woodpeckers, which tend to live in smaller groups in highly fragmented landscapes. Changing the land around live oaks may therefore change how many galls survive and how large they grow.

The wasp can be a nursery pest. One Texas record describes an infestation on live oak saplings in a tree nursery. The sources say nothing about how fire, water management or harvest rules affect it.

Life history

Food habits

The larvae feed only on their host oak, from inside the gall. The recorded hosts are southern live oak, sand live oak, Texas live oak and dwarf live oak. As in other gall wasps, the gall is lined with nutritious tissue that the larva feeds on. In this genus the grubs have chewing mouthparts but apparently don't use them to chew. They lap up the nutrients the gall gives off. In effect, the wasp makes the oak grow a pantry around each of its young. The sources do not say what adults eat, if anything.

Life cycle

Only half of this wasp's life cycle is known. Many oak gall wasps alternate between two generations, one with males and females and one of females only. For this species, only the all-female generation has been found. It grows in the many-chambered galls on the new stems of live oaks. The other generation, with both sexes, has never been found, so no one has seen the egg-laying that starts the stem galls.

The galls are noticeable in fall and develop quickly. Each one holds several to many larvae, one to a chamber, and larger galls hold more. Gall wasps of this family can carry hundreds to thousands of eggs. In northeast Florida, galls on southern live oak collected in mid-December released adults between March 5 and 12. A Texas record shows that in early April some adults had already left their galls while others were still inside.

When the adults leave depends on the host. Gall wasps emerge earlier from southern live oak than from sand live oak, in step with southern live oak's earlier spring growth. The sources do not say how long each stage lasts or how many generations there are a year.

Conservation

The southern live oak stem gall wasp is not listed under the Endangered Species Act. The sources give no conservation status, population numbers or trend.

Besides birds, the wasp has a range of natural enemies. Five species of parasitoid wasps, from three families, attack its galls. Another gall wasp, Synergus batatoides, has been reared from its galls in Florida. Synergus batatoides is an inquiline, a lodger that lives inside a gall made by another species.

Cool facts

  • William Ashmead described this wasp in 1881 from Florida galls and called the gall potato-like, firm and white inside like a potato.
  • Only the all-female generation of this wasp is known, and its other generation, with both males and females, has never been found.
  • Ashmead counted fifteen wasps in a single gall, each in its own chamber walled off by a parchment-thin partition.
  • Bigger galls hold more wasps but draw more attacks from birds, and when birds were kept off trees for five years the galls grew about 12 percent larger.
  • Live oaks carry at least six, and possibly twelve, species of gall wasps.
  • New galls are silver-gray, while old ones stay on the tree for years, turning dark with mold and lichens and riddled with exit holes.
  • Gall wasps like this one are model systems for scientists studying natural selection and how new species form.

Where to find it

Everglades National Park

Feb, Sep, Nov

Not on the park's official species list; reported here on iNaturalist.

  • Pine rocklands100% of sightings

    About 14,228 acres in the park

From 3 research-grade iNaturalist sightings in the park, placed on the NPS vegetation map (2009).

Canaveral National Seashore

Jan, Mar, Nov

Not on the park's official species list; reported here on iNaturalist.

  • Coastal hammock75% of sightings

    About 3,733 acres in the park

From 4 research-grade iNaturalist sightings in the park, placed on the NPS vegetation map (2012).

  1. Trade-off between fecundity and survival generates stabilizing selection on gall size (PMC) (opens in a new tab), Ecology and Evolution / PubMed Central
  2. Trade-off between fecundity and survival generates stabilizing selection on gall size (Wiley) (opens in a new tab), Wiley, Ecology and Evolution
  3. Trade-off ... (NCBI PMC mirror) (opens in a new tab), NCBI
  4. Trade-off ... (DOAJ abstract) (opens in a new tab), DOAJ
  5. Trade-off ... (ResearchGate PDF) (opens in a new tab), Ecology and Evolution
  6. Callirhytis quercusbatatoides (agamic) (opens in a new tab), Gallformers
  7. Callirhytis quercusbatatoides (agamic) – Ashmead 1881 quote (opens in a new tab), Gallformers
  8. Cynipidae - Callirhytis quercusbatatoides (Texas record) (opens in a new tab), BugGuide
  9. Species Callirhytis quercusbatatoides - recent images (opens in a new tab), BugGuide
  10. Galls - Callirhytis quercusbatatoides (Sarasota Co., FL) (opens in a new tab), BugGuide
  11. Temporal isolation between sympatric host plants cascades across multiple trophic levels (PMC) (opens in a new tab), Biology Letters / PMC
  12. Temporal isolation between sympatric host plants ... (supplementary data) (opens in a new tab), Royal Society
  13. Synergus batatoides Ashmead 1885 (opens in a new tab), Zenodo
  14. Invertebrate Community Associated with the Asexual Generation of Bassettia pallida (opens in a new tab), bioRxiv
  15. Callirhytis Oak Gall Wasps (opens in a new tab), NC State Extension
  16. Callirhytis quercuspunctata : Insect & Mite Guide (opens in a new tab), UMass Amherst CAFE
  17. Spined or Horned Galls on Oaks in Florida (Entomology Circular 355) (opens in a new tab), Florida Dept. of Agriculture & Consumer Services
  18. Description of the sexual generation of Callirhytis quercuscornigera (opens in a new tab), Florida Entomologist / BioOne
  19. Bulletgalls Targeting Oaks (opens in a new tab), Ohio State University BYGL
  20. The Leafy Oak Gall Wasp (opens in a new tab), Don't Kill My Weeds (naturalist blog, quotes Dr. Scott Egan)
  21. Quercus tree named 'QVMTFS' (plant patent) (opens in a new tab), USPTO