Thin-lined Calligrapher

Toxomerus boscii

  1. Home
  2. Animals
  3. Invertebrates
  4. Thin-lined Calligrapher

Toxomerus boscii · Syrphidae, Diptera

invertebrate

Identification

Size & shape

The thin-lined calligrapher is a very small hover fly, 0.19–0.27 in (4.7–6.8 mm) long. That puts it at the small end of its genus, Toxomerus, whose species typically run 6–9 mm. Like other calligraphers, it has large eyes that take up about two-thirds of the head, with a small notch at the back edge.

Like all true flies, it has a single pair of wings. Its banded body looks like a bee's or wasp's, but it has far less hair than a bee.

Color pattern

The abdomen is marked with fine black lines on a yellow to golden background, like a pen drawing. In this genus the abdominal pattern is what tells the species apart. In the thin-lined calligrapher, two thin lines run down the center of the abdomen. The yellow stripe along each side of the top of the thorax is narrow, and each hind leg has a black ring around the thigh (femur). These two marks are the main ones for identification. On the side of the thorax, just above the legs, it lacks the small yellow spot that most other calligraphers have. The eyes of calligrapher flies range from red to black.

Color in calligrapher flies depends partly on temperature during the pupal stage. Adults that pupated in cold weather come out with a much darker abdomen, and those that pupated in warmth come out golden. This has been described for calligrapher flies in general, not tested for this species in particular.

Behavior

Calligrapher flies are named "hover flies" for the way they hang in the air between flowers. They sometimes buzz, and with their banded bodies they pass for small bees or wasps, though they have no stinger. They fly by day and tend to stay in one general area. In the genus, the most foraging happens early in the day and drops off by late afternoon. Males of the genus hover in the open to attract females, and in some species they defend a territory.

What a visitor is most likely to see is a tiny striped fly feeding on low flowers or resting on vegetation. Thin-lined calligraphers have been photographed feeding on Bidens alba and on nightshade in Florida. In South Carolina, one was photographed in October on park grass beside a pond.

Telling it apart

It can be identified from good photographs if you look carefully, but it is easily confused with two relatives, the margined calligrapher (Toxomerus marginatus) and Toxomerus geminatus. Experienced observers have also mixed them up: one Florida photo first labeled as this species was later corrected to the margined calligrapher based on its abdominal pattern.

Look at the side of the thorax first. The thin-lined calligrapher lacks the small yellow spot just above the legs, and so does T. geminatus, but nearly all other calligraphers have it. To separate it from T. geminatus, check the rear edge of the third abdominal segment: T. geminatus has a thick black border there and the thin-lined calligrapher does not. The margined calligrapher has a small, round black spot near the tip of the abdomen. Beyond that, look for the narrow yellow stripe along the side of the thorax and the black ring on the hind thigh.

Size helps a little, though the ranges overlap. The thin-lined calligrapher is 4.7–6.8 mm and the margined calligrapher 4.9–5.7 mm. T. geminatus is somewhat larger at 6.1–7.6 mm, and Toxomerus politus is larger still at 7–9 mm.

Male and female

No differences between the sexes have been described for this species. In calligrapher flies generally, the male's eyes meet or nearly meet on top of the head, while the female's are set wider apart, with the small simple eyes (ocelli) visible between them.

Length
0.19–0.27 in (4.7–6.8 mm)

Habitat & cover

Habitat requirements

The sources say little about this species' habitat needs. Adults have been recorded in open places with flowers: in yards on nightshade, in a park in north Florida, and on mown grass beside a pond. In north Georgia they were trapped in apple and peach orchards, both at the edges and in the interior, and made up about 4.1 percent of the hover flies caught there (20 individuals).

The larvae are predators, so they need plants that carry populations of their soft-bodied prey. In the related T. geminatus, larvae live on vegetation with aphids and mites. No information was found on the soils, patch size or water this species needs.

Shelter

Nothing is recorded about shelter for this species in particular, or about where it overwinters in Florida. In its genus, last-stage larvae spend the winter and pupate in spring. One source says pupation takes place in the soil, while another describes the pupa as convex and pear-shaped and attached to leaves or stems. The related T. geminatus overwinters as a larva in Wisconsin and completes its change to an adult in spring.

Range & movements

The species has been recorded in central and north Florida and north along the Atlantic states through Georgia and South Carolina to Maryland. It does not occur in Minnesota. In Maryland, adults are on the wing mostly from late April through October.

Calligrapher flies are capable fliers but tend to stay in one general area. Nothing has been published on this species' home range, migration or dispersal.

Threats & management

Calligrapher larvae eat aphids and other plant pests, which makes them useful in gardens and on farms and can reduce the need for chemical control. Hover flies as a group are important generalist predators of aphids. This species turns up in orchards, both at the edges and among the trees. No information was found on how fire, water management or pesticides affect the thin-lined calligrapher itself.

Life history

Food habits

The larvae are predators. Larval diets are known for only nine species of Toxomerus, and the thin-lined calligrapher is one of the six recorded as predatory. Three others, including T. politus, feed on pollen instead. Larvae of the genus usually eat aphids, and they also take other true bugs, mites, thrips and the larvae of moths and butterflies.

Adult calligraphers feed on nectar and pollen from many kinds of plants, including grasses, sedges, figworts, heaths and broomrapes. Hover flies favor large, flat, pale flowers, and they may also lap up honeydew, the sugary liquid aphids give off. In Florida, adults have been recorded on Bidens alba and on nightshade.

Life cycle

The life cycle has four stages: egg, larva, pupa and adult, with three larval stages. The following comes from the genus as a whole, since stage lengths and generations per year have not been reported for this species. Fertilization is internal. Females lay up to 100 eggs one at a time on plants, in or near aphid colonies when the larvae are predators like this species'. The parents give no care. The larva feeds, molts twice and then pupates. Last-stage larvae can pass the winter before pupating in spring.

Adult calligraphers live about a month, less in summer and longer in winter. Some species, such as the margined calligrapher, produce several generations a year.

Conservation

The thin-lined calligrapher is not listed under the Endangered Species Act. In Maryland, near the northern edge of its known range, it is described as uncommon, with 20 records. Nothing has been published on its population trend, threats or conservation measures.

Cool facts

  • Calligrapher flies are named for the fine black lines on the abdomen, which look like pen-and-ink lettering.
  • With its striped body and buzz it passes for a bee or wasp, but it has no stinger.
  • The genus Toxomerus has more than 130 described species in the Americas.
  • Unlike some relatives whose larvae eat pollen, thin-lined calligrapher larvae are predators, and in this genus they mainly eat aphids.
  • At 4.7–6.8 mm long it is about the size of many native bees, which often surprises people.
  • Calligrapher flies that pupate in cold weather come out with a much darker abdomen than those that pupate in warmth.
  • Pollen sticks to a hover fly's body, hairs and legs, so it carries pollen from flower to flower.

Where to find it

Written by

  • Owner & Lead Guide

    Eric founded Viking EcoTours in 2021 after earning a B.S. in Wildlife Conservation from Virginia Tech and leading conservation crews with the Student Conservation Association.

  1. Common Hover Flies of Georgia: An Introductory Guide (opens in a new tab), University of Georgia CAES
  2. Toxomerus (Calligrapher Flies): Identification, Facts, and Taxonomy (opens in a new tab), Bugs With Mike
  3. About Thin-lined Calligrapher - Maryland Biodiversity Project (opens in a new tab), Maryland Biodiversity Project
  4. Syrphid Fly (Toxomerus sp. likely boscii) (opens in a new tab), Central Florida Critter of the Day
  5. #NatureZen: Calligrapher Flies (opens in a new tab), Overton Park Conservancy
  6. Eastern Calligrapher (Toxomerus geminatus) — Minnesota Seasons (opens in a new tab), Minnesota Seasons
  7. Syrphid Fly - Toxomerus boscii - BugGuide.Net (opens in a new tab), BugGuide
  8. Thin-lined Calligrapher - Toxomerus boscii - BugGuide.Net (opens in a new tab), BugGuide
  9. A second New World hoverfly, Toxomerus floralis, recorded from the Old World (Zootaxa) (opens in a new tab), Zootaxa
  10. Toxomerus (Calligrapher Flies) animal account (opens in a new tab), Animal Diversity Web, University of Michigan
  11. Eastern Calligrapher Fly (Family Syrphidae) (opens in a new tab), UW-Milwaukee Field Station
  12. Calligrapher Flies (Genus Toxomerus) (opens in a new tab), iNaturalist Canada
  13. Hover fly diversity and seasonality in North Georgia apple and peach orchards (opens in a new tab), Journal of Economic Entomology
  14. Backyard Blog February and March 2020 (opens in a new tab), WFSU
  15. Flies of North Florida are More Diverse than You'd Think (opens in a new tab), WFSU
  16. Minnesota Seasons - margined calligrapher (opens in a new tab), Minnesota Seasons
  17. Fly in Sharpes, United States (opens in a new tab), Project Noah
  18. Toxomerus geminatus (Eastern Calligrapher) (opens in a new tab), Bugs With Mike